A new technology acceptance model: a mixed-method of grounded theory and system dynamics

Abstract

Purpose The Iranian construction industry has been grappling with numerous problems in recent years, including rework, high costs and design errors. Engineers in this field have always highlighted the use of modern technological methods of construction to improve quality and productivity and reduce time and cost. One of these technologies is the so-called building information modeling (BIM), which has been very difficult to adopt and implement in Iran. The purpose of this study is to propose a systemic and holistic model to analyze the dynamics of adoption and implementation of BIM in this country. The purpose of this paper is to understand the dynamics of BIM acceptance to identify the most effective policy to maximize it in the Iranian manufacturing industry. Design/methodology/approach A two-stage methodology has been developed to achieve the purpose of the research. In the first stage, a technology acceptance model for BIM acceptance was developed using the grounded theory (GT) method. This conceptual model provides a holistic basis for building a simulation model. Thus, in the second stage, we used the dynamics system methodology to extract a dynamic model from the conceptual one. This dynamic model can simulate different policies and may be used to evaluate their respective effectiveness. Findings In this study, using the GT method, we obtained 510 primary codes, 118 secondary codes, 50 concepts and 17 categories. After determining the relationships between categories through axial coding, we reached a conceptual model based on selective coding. Mention some of the variables of the conceptual model. Awareness, security, perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use are some of the most important variables of this model. In the next part, this conceptual model was run using system dynamics and, thus, turned into a causal model in which all the effective variables on BIM technology and their relationships with each other are specified. The stock and flow diagram of the problem and its related equations were presented. To improve the model and solve the problem, we examined the four policies as four future scenarios on the model: continuing the status quo, development of specialist workforce training, bolstering governmental support and increasing awareness via advertisement within. The simulation results showed that government support is the most effective policy for maximizing BIM acceptance in Iran. Practical implications In addition to enumerating all the factors affecting BIM technology, this paper proposes a systemic model that provides an accurate and comprehensive view of the acceptance of this technology. In this regard, by introducing feedback loops, as well as reinforcing and balancing factors versus factors causing stasis, the model offers a much deeper insight into mechanisms associated with BIM development and its barriers. Therefore, this study provides a very useful perspective and basis for policy-makers and all stakeholders to accept and implement BIM technology. The findings of this study can lead to more accurate policy-making, removal of acceptance barriers, promotion of incentives, and consequently more effective acceptance of BIM technology. Originality/value In this study, a new mixed research method was used. The innovation of our study lies in its simultaneous use of GT method to construct an accurate and holistic model and applying the system dynamics methodology to build a holistic and systemic model of the BIM acceptance problem. This research also provides a suitable standard and tool for studying BIM technology in developing countries.

Conflict or coexistence? Synergies between nature conservation and traditional tea industry development in Wuyishan National Park, China

“…System dynamics could be used to systematically assess certain policy changes and impacts, while also interpreting undefined and unintended outcomes in policies, and helping researchers to better understand complex systems beyond the policy context (Sterman, 2018). The combination of grounded theory and system dynamics can effectively identify the main factors of action in dynamic systems, while visualizing the feedback loops in systems through CLD (Šviráková and Bianchi, 2018;Bastan et al, 2021). Thus, this mixed-method can reveal system characteristics and modes of action more intuitively and provide a new method of qualitative system dynamics with retrospective and anticipatory effects for system research.…”

Identification of critical paths leading to cost claims for underground metro projects: a system dynamics approach

“…Likewise, Love et al (2010) deployed causal modeling to identify the underlying dynamics influencing disputes. Bastan et al (2022) utilized a causal model to explore the interrelationships among the factors affecting BIM technology adoption in the Iranian context. Given the potentials of this approach, it is applied in this study as well to visualize and analyze how the causes of claims are related to each other.…”

Technology Adoption in Small-Medium Enterprises based on Technology Acceptance Model: A Critical Review

“…3 Extended Model of TAM (TAM2) [22] TAM was used between 1986-2003 to analyse user acceptance in different types of technologies ranging from communication, general-purpose, office and specialised business systems [23]. Recent studies also showed its application in studying building information modelling [26], digital payment systems [5], [27] , financial technology [4] and knowledge management [8]. According to [9], TAM has a robust implication on technology adoption from both theoretical and conceptual perspectives.…”