“…Of course, one can find single solitary wave solutions for equations that are not completely integrable like the Schamel equation 12,13 and extensions of it discussed by Das and Sarma. 1 ͑4͒ Finally, it is equally misleading to claim that dusty plasmas were included among the possible applications of the early literature on nonlinear waves in multicomponent plasmas, as in the paper by Das and Tagare. 14 Although, with hindsight, we can now apply the formalisms developed in these papers to waves in dusty plasmas with constant dust charges, one cannot say that these papers predicted dusty plasma modes, because in these papers there is no reference whatsoever to dusty plasmas.…”