A new agent-based model provides insight into deep uncertainty faced in simulated forest management

Abstract

ContextExploratory modeling in forestry uses a variety of approaches to study forest management questions.One key assumption that every approach makes is about the degree of deep uncertainty-the lack of knowledge required for making an informed decision-that future forest managers will face. This assumption can strongly in uence simulation results and the conclusions drawn from them, but is rarely studied. ObjectivesOur objective was to measure the degree of deep uncertainty within a forest management simulation to compare alternative modeling approaches and improve understanding of when a speci c approach should be applied. MethodsWe rst developed a method for measuring the degree of deep uncertainty assumed by approaches to modeling forest management. Next, we developed a new extension to the LANDIS-II model, the SOSIEL Harvest Extension, which simulates alternative approaches to modeling forest management. Finally, we applied the new method and extension to comparing three alternative approaches to modeling forest management in Michigan. ResultsThe degrees of deep uncertainty varied substantially among the three modeling approaches. There is also an overall negative relationship between the degree of deep uncertainty an approach assumes a forest manager will face and the level of exibility the approach assumes a manager will have in responding to forest change. ConclusionsQuantifying the deep uncertainty inherent in simulated forest management and comparing it across models provides an opportunity to better understand its sources and investigate differences in the assumptions made by alternative modeling approaches.

Untitled

“…Значительные возможности для решения проблемы эффективного использования лесных ресурсов территорий предоставляет инструментарий агент-ориентированного моделирования (Гулин, Антонов, 2017;Huff et al, 2015). Его весомым преимуществом является возможность учитывать динамику изменения характеристик исследуемых сущностей во времени и их пространственного размещения, а также структуру взаимосвязей между исследуемыми сущностями (Arifin, Madey, 2015;Janssen, 2017;Scholz et al, 2017;Holm et al, Fitzpatrick, 2018;Zupko, Rouleau, 2019;Scholz et al, 2021;Sotnik et al, 2021). Проблема заключается в том, что построение таких моделей осуществляется без использования формализованной методологической основы.…”