A narrative-based approach to understand the impact of COVID-19 on the mental health of stranded immigrants in four border cities in Mexico

Abstract

ObjectiveThis paper describes the impact that the different COVID-19 related restrictions have had on the mental health and wellbeing of 57 Central American and Caribbean immigrants stranded in Mexico due to the pandemic.MethodsEthnographic data was obtained through the application of in-depth interviews centered on topics such as migration history, personal experience with COVID-19 and beliefs about the pandemic. This information was further analyzed through a narrative approach and Atlas Ti.Main findingsUS Title 42 and the Migrant Protection Protocols (MPP) have stranded thousands of individuals in the US-Mexico border region, a situation that has overcrowded the available shelters in the area and forced many of the immigrants to live on the streets and in improvised encampments. Thus, exposing them to a higher risk of contagion. Furthermore, the majority of the interviewed Central American and Caribbean immigrants consider that Mexico is more lenient when it comes to the enforcement of sanitary measures, especially when compared to their countries of origin. Finally, vaccination hesitancy was low among the interviewees, mainly due to the operative aspects of the vaccination effort in Mexico and the fear of ruining their chances to attain asylum in the US. These findings are backed up by the discovery of five recurring narratives among the interviewees regarding: (1) The pandemic's psychological impact. (2) The uncertainty of being stranded in Mexico and the long wait. (3) Their fear of violence over the fear of contagion. (4) The perceived leniency of Mexico with the pandemic when compared to their countries of origin, and (5) their beliefs about the pandemic and vaccines.Key findingThe mental health of stranded Central American and Caribbean immigrants in Mexico during the COVID-19 pandemic is mostly affected by their inability to make it across the US-Mexico border using legal means.

Using Methodological Dilemmas to Produce an Enriching Research Opportunity: Case of a Study on Therapeutic Withdrawal in End-of-Life Care in Togo

“…Analysis option is to focus on the "storyteller" and the "story" (Riessman, 2008). Questions of validity have not been considered, as they are not directly applicable to narrative research (Bernasconi, 2015;Cruz Piñeiro & Ibarra, 2022). The advantage of using a narrative approach was that it gave each patient interviewed the freedom to recount their experiences with little intervention from the principal researcher.…”

Dinámica de movilidad y salud de mujeres migrantes en México, en el contexto de la pandemia Covid-19, 2021-2022

“…[3][4][5][6][7] Desde el inicio de la pandemia, la mayor parte de los países centroamericanos 8 y EEUU 9 cerraron sus fronteras, lo que ocasionó que personas migrantes en tránsito quedaran varadas en estaciones migratorias, albergues, campamentos improvisados o en situación de calle. 6,10 Las consecuencias de esta medida fueron de diferente tipo: se incrementó el riesgo de problemas de salud mental 11 y de contraer Covid-19, 12 y ocurrieron importantes tensiones sociopolíticas en las relaciones entre sociedad y gobierno, y entre los gobiernos de la región. 8 A pesar del cierre de fronteras, lo que tuvo importantes consecuencias en la movilidad internacional en la región, la migración continuó con una participación significativa de las mujeres como migrantes irregulares, solicitantes de asilo y refugiadas.…”