A Multi-Criteria Approach to Rank the Municipalities of the States of Mexico by its Marginalization Level: The Case of Jalisco

López, Juan Carlos; Noriega, Jesús Jaime Solano; Chavira, Diego Alonso Gastélum

doi:10.1142/s0219622017500080

Cited by 11 publications

(3 citation statements)

References 46 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Unclassified

Order By: Relevance

“…The ELECTRE III method developed by (Roy, 1978) and recently applied by Lopez et al (2017); Leoneti, (2016);Hodgett, (2016) and involves two steps:…”

Section: Description Of the Electre III Methodsmentioning

confidence: 99%

Classifying the integrated public safety areas (IPSAs): a multi-criteria based approach

Basílio

Pereira

Costa

2019

JM2

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Purpose This study aims to focus on the application of a multiple criteria decision analysis (MCDA) method to compare results presented by the Integrated Goals System based on the 12th edition of the Integrated Public Safety Areas (IPSAs) Award, which achieved goals established for Strategic Crime Indicators for the state of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. The main objective of this research was to limit the compensatory effects of classification criteria on IPSAs that have achieved goals established for crime indicators by applying the MCDA method. Design/methodology/approach The methodology was based on the application of MCDA. The MCDA method selected and used was ELECTRE III, being implemented by J-Electre software. Findings Compared to results of the current method, the results of the ELECTRE III method showed a 94.87 per cent change in ranking positions revealed via the SIM method. This finding denotes the elimination of compensatory effects of the criteria. As a consequence, it can be affirmed that the application of resources by IPSA managers to reduce the prevalence of a single strategic crime indicator is no longer a success factor for awarding in the established goal system. Research limitations/implications As limitations, it is possible to indicate the time cut used to carry out the research. The research may be extended to other issues of the productivity award. Practical implications The methodology applied with the use of ELECTRE III revealed that the government could reduce the cost with the incentive program to reduce criminal indices. Social implications As the MCDA method is based on a binary pairwise comparison system, the methodology imposes a change of attitude on local managers fighting crime to reduce crime indicators and to consequently build a local sense of safety in IPSAs. Originality/value This research fills a gap in the literature because there are few studies using the MCDA method in the field of public security. The value of the work lies in the creation of a method that gives the decision-maker, of the law enforcement agency, an alternative to improve the process of rewarding by productividad of the integrated areas of public security.

show abstract

“…The ELECTRE III method developed by (Roy, 1978) and recently applied by Lopez et al (2017); Leoneti, (2016);Hodgett, (2016) and involves two steps:…”

Section: Description Of the Electre III Methodsmentioning

confidence: 99%

Classifying the integrated public safety areas (IPSAs): a multi-criteria based approach

Basílio

Pereira

Costa

2019

JM2

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…Em relação à aplicação de pesos para os critérios, somente o método ELECTRE IV não aplica pesos para os critérios. O método utilizado para resolução do problema foi o ELECTRE III desenvolvido por (Roy, 1978) sendo aplicado, por exemplo por: (Lopez, Noriega, & Chavira, 2017), (Leoneti, 2016), e (Hodgett, 2016), (Infante, Mendonça, & Valle, 2014…”

Section: Aplicação De Mcda Na Segurança Públicaunclassified

Método Electre Iii Aplicado Na Modelagem Do Processo De Acesso a Alta Gestão Em Órgão De Segurança Pública

Basílio¹,

Pereira²

2017

Anais Do Encontro Nacional De Engenharia De Produção

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

O presente estudo objetivou reduzir o efeito compensatório dos critérios de escolha nos processo de promoção funcional de acesso aos cargos de alta gestão em órgão de segurança pública no Estado do Rio de Janeiro, por meio da aplicação de método multicritério de apoio à decisão-MCDA. Em relação aos fins pode-se classificar a pesquisa como metodológica e aplicada. Quanto aos meios como bibliográfica, documental, e de laboratório. A pesquisa bibliográfica identificou que há poucos estudos de MCDA aplicados ao campo de segurança pública. A pesquisa documental proporcionou a descrição do sistema vigente no órgão pesquisado. Em laboratório foi utilizado o software J-Electre, que a partir dos dados coletados gerou as matrizes de concordância, discordância, de credibilidade e rank final, do método ELECTRE III, dos 124 candidatos que integravam o quadro de acesso por merecimento a promoção ao posto de coronel da Polícia Militar, em dezembro de 2016. Os resultados, revelam que o processo de classificação resultante da modelagem do problema com o Método ELECTRE III, apresenta eliminação do efeito compensatório, o que resultou em uma alteração de posição em 93,55 % em relação ao modelo atual em utilização na Polícia Militar do Estado do Rio de XXXVII ENCONTRO NACIONAL DE ENGENHARIA DE PRODUCAO "A Engenharia de Produção e as novas tecnologias produtivas: indústria 4.0, manufatura aditiva e outras abordagens avançadas de produção"

show abstract

“…Due to human cognitive limitations, and the number of compared elements, the size of pairwise comparison matrices (PCMs) must be small. However, in the current information era, the information collected from databases and the internet is also susceptible to being handled as pairwise comparisons -and these collections can be huge (see [1,2,3], among others). In general, in highly complex problems, the number of elements to be compared may be very large.…”

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 99%

Consistent clustering of entries in large pairwise comparison matrices

Benítez

Carpitella

Certa

et al. 2018

Journal of Computational and Applied Mathematics

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

In multi-attribute decision making the number of decision elements under consideration may be huge, especially for complex, real-world problems. Typically these elements are clustered and then the clusters organized hierarchically to reduce the number of elements to be simultaneously handled. These decomposition methodologies are intended to bring the problem within the cognitive ability of decision makers. However, such methodologies have disadvantages, and it may happen that such a priori clustering is not clear, and/or the problem has previously been addressed without any grouping action. This is the situation for the case study we address, in which a panel of experts gives opinions about the operation of 15 previously established district metered areas in a real water distribution system. Large pairwise comparison matrices may also be found when building comparisons of elements using large bodies of information. In this paper, we address a consistent compression of an AHP comparison matrix that collapses the judgments corresponding to a given number of compared elements. As a result, an a posteriori clustering of various elements becomes possible. In our case study, such a clustering offers several added benefits, including the identification of hidden or unknown criteria to cluster the considered elements of the problem.

show abstract

A Multi-Criteria Approach to Rank the Municipalities of the States of Mexico by its Marginalization Level: The Case of Jalisco

Cited by 11 publications

References 46 publications

Classifying the integrated public safety areas (IPSAs): a multi-criteria based approach

Classifying the integrated public safety areas (IPSAs): a multi-criteria based approach

Método Electre Iii Aplicado Na Modelagem Do Processo De Acesso a Alta Gestão Em Órgão De Segurança Pública

Consistent clustering of entries in large pairwise comparison matrices

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About