A missing piece of the puzzle of on-farm freshwater restoration: What motivates land managers to record and report land management actions?

Abstract

Worldwide, progress has been made toward managing productive lands more sustainably to improve freshwater health. However, a lack of national guidance for environmental reporting and recording means that it is not possible to quantify consistently which land management actions that help improve water quality have been implemented, where, when, and to what extent. This situation suggests that information on the effectiveness of these actions is missing or fragmented. Systematic recording and reporting of land management actions is an important piece of a large freshwater restoration puzzle. We investigated what motivates New Zealand land managers to record their actions and report them to their networks by conducting 23 semi-structured interviews. Between February and November 2020, we spoke with food producers, New Zealand Indigenous people of the land tāngata whenua community members, and government and industry representatives. The key themes that described motivators for these land managers to record and report land management actions were collective engagement (e.g., working with catchment care groups), identity and social norms (e.g., being a "socially approved" farmer), and efficient farm management (e.g., using one simple recording tool for multiple purposes to save time). While these findings will be broadly germane to international contexts, they are being used specifically to inform the development of a proposed National Register of Land Management Actions in Aotearoa New Zealand.

Collective storytelling as a river restoration tool: The role of catchment communities in inspiring environmental change

“…Previous research has highlighted the value of "catchment champions" as storytellers to encourage freshwater restoration (Gearey, 2018;Doehring et al, 2022). Our findings, too, suggest that having an inspiring storyteller is important for Catchment Journeys to enthuse others within their own catchment.…”

“…However, for change to happen, communities not only need to understand restoration actions, but need to be motivated to undertake them [Society for Ecological Restoration International (SER) Science & Policy Working Group., 2004;Aronson et al, 2006]. It is well understood that motivation is triggered, and sustained, if knowledge is shared between rural communities, as opposed to "top-down" information provision (Society for Ecological Restoration International (SER) Science & Policy Working Group, 2004;Doehring et al, 2022). Based on this, we explored the role catchment communities .…”