A mini-review of end-of-life management of wind turbines: Current practices and closing the circular economy gap

Abstract

Renewable energy generation and increased electrification are pivotal to reducing greenhouse gas emissions and mitigating climate change. Consequently, global deployment of wind turbines has soared, and the trend is expected to continue. Installed turbines have only recently started reaching the end of their design lives, and waste volumes are projected to escalate rapidly. Approximately 94% of a wind turbine (by mass) is recyclable, but the waste polymer composite blades are most commonly landfilled. This mini-review aims to review current end-of-life (EoL) management practices in the large-scale wind industry for countries with established EoL standards as well as those with less mature regulations. Data on current EoL management practices, initiatives and regulations in industry was sourced primarily from literature reviews and publicly available internet information. Additional insights and perspectives were gained from WindEurope’s EoL Issues and Strategies 2020 seminar and through communication with select individuals from various sectors such as wind energy development and operations, government, industry associations, academia and research organizations. The results show that the decision on EoL options is dictated by the remaining useful life (RUL) of the wind turbines, prevailing policies and electricity prices. The contribution of this article is, firstly, identifying a number of key technical, economic and regulatory questions that must be asked before deciding on the most appropriate EoL option. Secondly, the article identifies factors that impede current EoL management efforts to close the circular economy gap and those that can support sustainable technology deployment. Finally, the article considers the way that countries with a young fleet of wind farms may learn from more experienced nations. There are few proven business cases, and barriers to the profitability and effectiveness of EoL strategies include uncertainty about the assets’ RUL, collection logistics, the size of wind farm operation margins, low waste feedstock and limited markets for recycled products. Designing for circularity, stakeholder collaboration, circular business models and technology-specific regulations can improve EoL sustainability. The research found that wind turbine EoL management is dynamic and complex and needs to consider multiple, often conflicting factors. However, it is necessary and has immense environmental, technical and economic potential as the industry matures and business cases are proven.

Circular solar: Evaluating the profitability of a photovoltaic panel recycling plant

“…The discounted cash flow (DCF) method is used to evaluate the economic profitability of a recycling plant. Specifically, net present value (NPV) is the chosen indicator that can consider both the time value of money and include the various estimated cash flows (Woo and Whale, 2022). It is a prediction of what might happen in the future but is still important as it highlights whether a market has economic potential or not.…”

Waste Management of Wind Turbine Blades: A Comprehensive Review on Available Recycling Technologies with A Focus on Overcoming Potential Environmental Hazards Caused by Microplastic Production

“…Regarding the management of EoL wind turbines, the available literature provides scarce information on the Indian context. Woo and Whale [53] state that repowering is the most active option in India, where the Wind Repowering Policy for turbines 1 MW and below is in force.…”

Advances in the Supply Chain and Circular Economy towards Sustainability

“…A transformational shift has occurred in the 21st century, with many enterprises in the manufacturing or service sectors adopting sustainable and circular approaches and abandoning linear and wasteful processes [1][2][3]. With the scarcity of resources becoming increasingly apparent, businesses are now taking swift action to implement supply chain technology and initiate circular economy strategies.…”