A comparison of student reactions to biology instruction by interactive videodisc or conventional laboratory

Abstract

This study was designed to learn if students perceived an interactive computer/videodisc learning system to represent a viable alternative to (or extension of) the conventional laboratory for learning biology skills and concepts normally taught under classroom laboratory conditions. Data were collected by questionnaire for introductory biology classes at a large midwestern university where students were randomly assigned to two interactive videodisc/computer lessons titled Respiration and Climate and Life or traditional laboratory investigation with the same titles and concepts. The interactive videodisc system consisted of a TRS-80 Model III microcomputer interfaced to a Pioneer laser-disc player and a color TV monitor. Students indicated an overall level satisfaction with this strategy very similar to that of conventional laboratory instruction. Students frequently remarked that videodisc instruction gave them more experimental and procedural options and more efficient use of instructional time than did the conventional laboratory mode. These two results are consistent with past CAI research. Students also had a strong perception that the images on the videodisc "were not real" and this factor was perceived as having both advantages and disadvantages. Students found the two approaches to be equivalent to conventional laboratory instruction in the areas of general interest, understanding of basic principles, help on examinations, and attitude toward science. The student-opinion data in this study do not suggest that interactive videodisc technology serve as a substitute to the "wet" laboratory experience, but that this medium may enrich the spectrum of educational experiences usually not possible in typical classroom settings.A number of justifications for computer-assisted instruction (CAI) in science education have been offered since it was first introduced about two decades ago.Among the early ones were economizing on laboratory facilities and materials, saving instructional time, individualization of student work, drill and practice, and rapid evaluation of student response and feedback. As computers became more sophisticated, rationale expanded to highly motivating and interactive simulations and games which enrich the educational experience, ability to manipulate abstract 0

Wise: Web Interface for Statistics Education

“…Statistics educators must be alert to new and interesting ways to make the topic stimulating and relevant. The use of multimedia technological supplements, such as computerassisted instruction, is one way to address these issues and to accomplish the goal of engaging students in statistics education (Leonard, 1989;Moore, Cobb, Garfield, & Meeker, 1995).…”

A comparison of student performance following instruction by interactive videodisc versus conventional laboratory

“…In another study, students expressed approximately the same satisfaction with biology instruction by interactive videodisc and with biology instruction by conventional laboratory methods, (Leonard, 1989). Students frequently remarked that videodisc instruction gave them more experimental and procedural options, as well as more efficient use of instructional time than did the conventional laboratory mode.…”

The effects of computer simulation models on middle school students' understanding of the anatomy and morphology of the frog

“…In a second study, Leonard (1989) investigated the effectiveness of teaching about respiration and climate by using two videodisc systems in two introductory college biology laboratory sections (twenty studaits each). Students were randomly assigned to either the interactive videodisc expaimental group or the traditional laboratory group.…”