A comparative study of multi-objective optimization methodologies for molecular and process design

Abstract

The need to consider multiple objectives in molecular design, whether based on techno-economic, environmental or health and safety metrics is increasingly recognized. There is, however, limited understanding of the suitability of different multi-objective optimization algorithm for the solution of such design problems. In this work, we present a systematic comparison of the performance of five mixed-integer non-linear programming (MINLP) multi-objective optimization algorithms on the selection of computer-aided molecular design (CAMD) and computer-aided molecular and process design (CAMPD) problems. The five methods are designed to address the discrete and nonlinear nature of the problem, with the aim of generating an accurate approximation of the Pareto front. They include: a weighted sum approach without global search phases (SWS), a weighted sum approach with simulated annealing (SA), a weighted sum approach with multi level single linkage (MLSL), the sandwich algorithm with MLSL and the non dominated sorting genetic algorithm-II (NSGA-II). The algorithms are compared systematically in two steps. The effectiveness of the global search methods is evaluated with SWS, WSSA and WSML. WSML is found to be most effective and a comparative analysis of WSML, SDML and NSGA-II is then undertaken. As a test set of these optimization techniques,

Accelerating manufacturing for biomass conversion via integrated process and bench digitalization: a perspective

“…169 • Product and process design. [170][171][172][173][174] These problems are numerically difficult due to including many nonlinear and integer variables, many components, and complex property estimation. Approaches to overcome the complexity include (1) surrogates 172 and clustering and averaging techniques; 175 (2) a hierarchical approach [175][176][177] to screen, using the most relevant material properties and processes, and determine the optimal molecule using more rigorous models; and (3) an iterative scheme by formulating a single optimization 170 or two optimizations 171 where the "master problem" selects the optimal path and a detailed nonlinear optimizer determines the optimal process conditions.…”

Simultaneous Optimization of Process Design and Solvent in a Flowsheet Simulator

“…There have been previous works to include MCO in the search for optimal process fluids. They can be distinguished into two categories: First, into works where various properties of the optimized fluid are considered as the problem objectives [31,32], and second, into works that solve the multicriteria optimization problem using process objectives directly [12,19,34].…”

Process modelling and life cycle assessment coupled with experimental work to shape the future sustainable production of chemicals and fuels

“…Another topic that remains largely unexplored is the multi-objective molecular design of chemicals with minimum environmental footprint. 149 The goal here would be to minimise the life cycle impact of molecules meeting some specifications. The scope of this assessment could be enlarged further to cover the use-phase of the chemical, which would require combining process simulation and molecular design constraints within a single model; this approach would be particularly appealing for the assessment of solvents.…”