X-ray absorption spectroscopic studies from several different groups provide a consistent structural picture of methanol synthesis catalysts. Copper metal is the principal Cu species detected in all in-situ XAS studies. A small amount of Cu(II) persisted in many samples reduced below 600 K, but it appears to be catalytically irrelevant. Cu(I) was not detected in any of the in-situ XAS studies. The Zn structure did not change in response to chemical treatments in any of the ZnO-containing methanol synthesis catalysts.We conclude that the slow approach to steady-state rate of methanol synthesis from CO/H 2 mixtures cannot result from changes in the Cu metal component of Cu/SiO 2 catalysts. By eliminating this possibility, we provide indirect evidence for the proposal that initial induction periods reflect slow changes in the surface of the SiO 2 or ZnO component in the catalysts. A bifunctional mechanism involving the formation of formate from CO on support hydroxyl groups would increase methanol synthesis rates as OH groups are formed by hydrolysis of Si-O bonds using the H 2 O formed in slow methanation side reactions. The bifunctional mechanism is not required for the synthesis of methanol from CO 2 -containing mixtures, because formate can form on Cu directly from CO 2 and H 2 .