Nanocomposites were prepared by melt blending of multiwalled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs) filled with polyvinylidene fluoride. Time-dependent piezoresistance was investigated as a function of concentration. In the quasi-static case, a transition from negative pressure coefficient to positive pressure coefficient (PPC) behavior was observed. The PPC effect was negligible at high concentrations. At short times, the resistive response decreased for all nanocomposites, with the magnitude of the decrease proportionate to the MWCNT concentration. However, long-term creep response was resistive for low concentrations and conductive at high concentrations. A Burgers model based on Maxwell and Kelvin elements in series was used to describe the strain dependence. An equivalent model that uses resistances and capacitances was examined for the time dependence of fractional resisitivity. Results were correlated with Raman mapping-based dispersion analysis. An increased dispersion and an increase in MWCNT-MWCNT contact area resulted in a transition from a matrix-based resistive response to a filler-based conductive response.