Matching Message Design and Depressed Cognition: An Exploration of Attention Patterns for Gain- and Loss-Framed Depression Help-Seeking Messages

Abstract

Although disproportionally affected by depression, most depressed college students do not seek the help they need. Research has recently uncovered the potential negative effects of depression help-seeking messages if depressed cognition is not considered in the health message design process. It is unclear if depression determines whether and how individuals pay attention to gain- and loss-framed depression help-seeking messages-a mechanism that has significant implications for the strategic planning of health communication interventions. In order to enable the effective matching of message design and audience features, this study investigated attention patterns for gain (n = 75)- and loss (n = 78)-framed depression help-seeking messages using eye-tracking technology and self-report measures. The results confirmed that depression is a characteristic of risk avoidance and negative cognition. Depressed participants tended to pay more attention to disease information that was placed in a loss-framed rather than a gain-framed depression help-seeking message. Using negative message framing strategies for health messages seeking to educate about depression symptoms might therefore be a useful persuasive strategy-particularly when disseminated to vulnerable populations affected by depression. Furthermore, the present study emphasizes the effective use of eye-tracking technology in communication research.

Communication strategies used by women to influence male partners to seek professional help for mental health problems: A qualitative study

“…In this study, it was clear from the women's behavioural and communication responses that they often took the stance that depression was negative and not treating it would lead to negative consequences. This has been found to be the most helpful technique for gaining attention to a ‘you are unwell’ message in those with moderate–severe depression (Lueck, ). It could therefore have the most potential to influence help‐seeking over a message about the positives of seeking help.…”

Responses to persuasive messages encouraging professional help seeking for depression: comparison between individuals with and without psychological distress

“…It seems reasonable that individuals with depression feel strongly sad when they are informed the loss-framed message, while they feel strongly happy when they are informed the gain-framed message, and also that individuals with depression think to keep the message. Recently, some investigators focused on whether increased levels of depressive symptomatology were associated with reduced help-seeking intentions [28, 29]. Since the study participants consisted of individuals with no or mild depressive symptoms, further studies may be needed to confirm the susceptibility to the messages for individuals with severe depressive symptoms.…”

What can clinicians do to improve outcomes across psychiatric treatments: a conceptual review of non-specific components

“…The majority of studies assessing the effect of treatment framing across different psychiatric conditions have focused on helpseeking behaviours and on the uptake of treatment. Findings from these studies have been mixed (O'Keefe and Jensen, 2007;Lueck, 2017) with more positive findings on treatment uptake than subsequent adherence (Mavandadi et al, 2017(Mavandadi et al, , 2018. Prospect theory may help explain this divergence (Tversky and Kahneman, 1979;Rothman et al, 2006).…”