What are the attributes of a good health educator?

Abstract

ObjectivesThe purpose of this study was to examine the attributes that students and educators believe are important to being a good health educator in a non-clinical setting. MethodsA cross-sectional survey of first-year health science students and educators involved with a Health Science course in Melbourne, Australia was performed. A convenience sampling approach was implemented, with participants were required to rate the importance of teaching attributes on a previously developed 15-item written questionnaire. Descriptive statistics were generated, with Pearson’s chi-square statistics used to examine differences between groups. In total 94/147 (63.9%) of students and 15/15 (100%) of educators participated in the study. ResultsOf the 15 attributes, only ‘scholarly activity’ was not deemed to be not as an important attribute to define a good educator. Knowledge base (50% vs. 13.3%) and feedback skills (22.3% vs. 0%) were rated as important attributes by students in comparison to educators. Professionalism (20% vs. 5.3%), scholarly activity (20% vs. 3.2%) and role modelling (26.7% vs. 3.2%) were rated as the most important attributes by educators in comparison to students. ConclusionsNo single attribute makes a good health educator; rather health educators are required to have a rounded approach to teaching. Students have greater focus on the educator providing a transfer of knowledge. Educators are additionally focused on professionalism attributes, which may not be valued by students. Students and educators must enter into a clearer understanding of expectations, from both parties, to obtain optimal education outcomes.

Needs Assessments of Medical Students in Obstetrics and Gynaecology

“…Feedback provides a two-way communication and provides a timely communication both positive and negative. 4 Almost, all the students wanted innovations in the method of teaching. The quality and quantity of theory classes, which form the backbone of medical classes in India does not seem to impress our young students.…”

“…Feedback from students is mandatory to improve teaching methods 4 . The input of the students for changing the system will be invaluable.…”

Teaching strategies for the clinical environment

“…At the start of the working relationship, taking a few minutes to meet with each learner is key to establishing a collaborative learning environment. Inquire about the learner's goals, and explain your expectations and how you plan to support the learner to achieve your mutual goals . Set an expectation for peer‐to‐peer teaching to help achieve those goals .…”

“…Inquire about the learner's goals, and explain your expectations and how you plan to support the learner to achieve your mutual goals. 1 Set an expectation for peer-topeer teaching to help achieve those goals. 2 Establish brief check-ins to discuss how things are progressing and provide feedback.…”

Near-peer mentoring: a reflection on the benefits and challenges from both sides of the table. A discursive piece from a mentor and four learners

“…Much research has gone into the analysis of what makes a good teacher, including elements of personality (Ilic, 2016). And this is no different with near-peer mentoring, the combination of enthusiasm, experience and creativity of the mentor definitely attributes to the success of the mentoring.…”