The “Handling” of power in the physician-patient encounter: perceptions from experienced physicians

Abstract

BackgroundModern healthcare is burgeoning with patient centered rhetoric where physicians “share power” equally in their interactions with patients. However, how physicians actually conceptualize and manage their power when interacting with patients remains unexamined in the literature. This study explored how power is perceived and exerted in the physician-patient encounter from the perspective of experienced physicians. It is necessary to examine physicians’ awareness of power in the context of modern healthcare that espouses values of dialogic, egalitarian, patient centered care.MethodsThirty physicians with a minimum five years’ experience practicing medicine in the disciplines of Internal Medicine, Surgery, Pediatrics, Psychiatry and Family Medicine were recruited. The authors analyzed semi-structured interview data using LeCompte and Schensul’s three stage process: Item analysis, Pattern analysis, and Structural analysis. Theoretical notions from Bourdieu’s social theory served as analytic tools for achieving an understanding of physicians’ perceptions of power in their interactions with patients.ResultsThe analysis of data highlighted a range of descriptions and interpretations of relational power. Physicians’ responses fell under three broad categories: (1) Perceptions of holding and managing power, (2) Perceptions of power as waning, and (3) Perceptions of power as non-existent or irrelevant.ConclusionsAlthough the “sharing of power” is an overarching goal of modern patient-centered healthcare, this study highlights how this concept does not fully capture the complex ways experienced physicians perceive, invoke, and redress power in the clinical encounter. Based on the insights, the authors suggest that physicians learn to enact ethical patient-centered therapeutic communication through reflective, effective, and professional use of power in clinical encounters.

Partner Notification: A Community Viewpoint

“…In some places, governments are given augmented authority to identify and contact the sex or injecting partners of people with HIV without consent. In other instances, healthcare providers may simply be perceived by the public to have such authority .…”

Utilizing eHealth and Telemedicine Technologies to Enhance Access and Quality of Consultations: It's Not What You Say, It's the Way You Say It

“…However, there is an inherent power imbalance in routine consultations between health care providers and their patients. 21 Physicians hold status and authority through the cultural and symbolic aspects of medicine. Although they exert this power during consultations, they have little conscious awareness that this is happening.…”

“…Although they exert this power during consultations, they have little conscious awareness that this is happening. 21 Because patients are vulnerable due to their need for health care, this paternalistic approach to patient-provider relationships immediately creates a power imbalance; patients become recipients of health care rather than partners in their disease management. This relationship is incongruent with the role patients must play in real life.…”

Development of a Japanese Version of a Collaborative Relationship Scale between Clients and Occupational Therapists

“…The 'power' used in this study is defined as a related, co-built process. 11) Because power exists in all interpersonal relationships, there are no interactions that are not related to OT. However, there can be impediments in the decision-making process between the client and occupational therapist, even in a truly client-centred practice.…”