Dutch senior medical students and disaster medicine: a national survey

Abstract

BackgroundMedical students have been deployed in victim care of several disasters throughout history. They are corner stones in first-line care in recent pandemic planning. Furthermore, every physician and senior medical student is expected to assist in case of disaster situations, but are they educated to do so? Being one of Europe’s densest populated countries with multiple nuclear installations, a large petrochemical industry and also at risk for terrorist attacks, The Netherlands bear some risks for incidents. We evaluated the knowledge on Disaster Medicine in the Dutch medical curriculum. Our hypothesis is that Dutch senior medical students are not prepared at all.MethodsSenior Dutch medical students were invited through their faculty to complete an online survey on Disaster Medicine, training and knowledge. This reported knowledge was tested by a mixed set of 10 theoretical and practical questions.ResultsWith a mean age of 25.5 years and 60 % females, 999 participants completed the survey. Of the participants, 51 % considered that Disaster Medicine should absolutely be taught in the regular medical curriculum and only 2 % felt it as useless; 13 % stated to have some knowledge on disaster medicine. Self-estimated capability to deal with various disaster situations varied from 1.47/10 in nuclear incidents to 3.92/10 in influenza pandemics. Self-estimated knowledge on these incidents is in the same line (1.71/10 for nuclear incidents and 4.27/10 in pandemics). Despite this limited knowledge and confidence, there is a high willingness to respond (ranging from 4.31/10 in Ebola outbreak over 5.21/10 in nuclear incidents to 7.54/10 in pandemics). The case/theoretical mix gave a mean score of 3.71/10 and raised some food for thought. Although a positive attitude, 48 % will place contaminated walking wounded in a waiting room and 53 % would use iodine tablets as first step in nuclear decontamination. Of the participants, 52 % even believes that these tablets protect against external radiation, 41 % thinks that these tablets limit radiation effects more than shielding and 57 % believes that decontamination of chemical victims consists of a specific antidote spray in military cabins.ConclusionsDespite a high willingness to respond, our students are not educated for disaster situations.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12245-015-0077-0) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Effects of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Medical Students: A Multicenter Quantitative Study

“…Previous international studies of medical student attitudes towards hypothetical in uenza-like pandemics demonstrated a willingness (80%) 4 and a perceived ethical obligation to volunteer (77% and 70%), despite 40% of Canadian students in one study perceiving a high likelihood of becoming infected. 5,6 Amidst the current COVID-19 pandemic, our participants reported less agreement with a medical student ethical obligation to volunteer in the clinical setting at 37.8%, but believed in a higher likelihood of becoming infected at 75.6%.…”

Are Belgian military students in medical sciences better educated in disaster medicine than their civilian colleagues?

“…20 Belgium has a limited introduction of such an educational programme in three faculties, 8 and the Netherlands has no disaster medicine programmes in their medical schools, but one faculty has expressed interest after participating in a recent national survey. 21 If these military student data are compared with those of a similar survey given to civilian senior master medical students, significantly higher score on self-estimated knowledge and capability is observed, although only 27% were senior master students; one exception regards the knowledge and capability of influenza pandemics. Results on willingness to work in various disaster scenarios are comparable between the two groups, and the results of the theoretical question/case section were significantly more favourable for the military student group.…”

Health Care Student Knowledge and Willingness to Work in Infectious Disease Outbreaks

“…However, the reported level of disaster knowledge was selfestimated, failing to reflect an objective relationship between medical student knowledge and willingness to respond. 12 Most nursing students report a professional obligation to volunteer in the event of a pandemic. Their WTW is even greater if adequate protection, such as PPE, is provided.…”