Are Belgian military students in medical sciences better educated in disaster medicine than their civilian colleagues?

Abstract

IntroductionHistorically, medical students have been deployed to care for disaster victims but may not have been properly educated to do so. A previous evaluation of senior civilian medical students in Belgium revealed that they are woefully unprepared. Based on the nature of their military training, we hypothesised that military medical students were better educated and prepared than their civilian counterparts for disasters. We evaluated the impact of military training on disaster education in medical science students.MethodsStudents completed an online survey on disaster medicine, training, and knowledge, tested using a mixed set of 10 theoretical and practical questions. The results were compared with those of a similar evaluation of senior civilian medical students.ResultsThe response rate was 77.5%, mean age 23 years and 59% were males. Overall, 95% of military medical students received some chemical, biological, radiological and nuclear training and 22% took part in other disaster management training; 44% perceived it is absolutely necessary that disaster management should be incorporated into the regular curriculum. Self-estimated knowledge ranged from 3.75 on biological incidents to 4.55 on influenza pandemics, based on a 10-point scale. Intention to respond in case of an incident ranged from 7 in biological incidents to 7.25 in chemical incidents. The mean test score was 5.52; scores improved with educational level attained. A comparison of survey data from civilian senior medical master students revealed that, except for influenza pandemic, military students scored higher on knowledge and capability, even though only 27% of them were senior master students. Data on willingness to work are comparable between the two groups. Results of the question/case set were significantly better for the military students.ConclusionsThe military background and training of these students makes them better prepared for disaster situations than their civilian counterparts.

Evaluation of Disaster Medicine Preparedness among Healthcare Profession Students: A Cross-Sectional Study in Pakistan

“…Among the aspects covered were chemical, biological, radiological, disease pandemic, and nuclear training. Their study found that military students scored higher on knowledge and capability and were better prepared for disaster situations than their civilian counterparts, that is, medical science students [42]. Ingrassia and coworkers studied the disaster management educational and training initiatives at the postgraduate level in EU countries and found that face-to-face education was the most common teaching method used.…”

“…Although German students were highly motivated, the majority were not well educated regarding disaster medicine [22]. A study in Belgium indicated that the respondents wanted to increase their knowledge in this area and welcomed the introduction of specific courses into the standard medical curriculum [42].…”

A Bibliometric Profile of Disaster Medicine Research from 2008 to 2017: A Scientometric Analysis

“…These papers focus on the practical elements of disaster medicine, including the treatment of wounded, effect evaluation, first aid, and disaster medical education. [48][49][50][51][52] (2) "Hospital disasters." These papers also focus on practical elements of disaster medicine, including modular management, humanitarian relief, first aid management processes, and disaster emergency departments.…”

Disaster E-Health Framework for Community Resilience

“…For a long time, disaster health was seen simply as an extension of conventional (non-disaster) emergency care and the literature [34,35] contains multiple complaints that the training of physicians does not prepare them for dealing with disasters and their aftermath. This situation is changing, encouraged by a better understanding of the unique, dynamic circumstances presented by disasters [18,21,36,37].…”