Configuration of power relations in physicians and nurses’ professional practices

Abstract

Objective: to analyze the configuration of power relations constituted in and by the knowledge and daily practices of physicians and nurses in an Intensive Care Unit (ICU). Method: qualitative study in which data were collected through interviews with physicians and nurses from an ICU of a hospital in Belo Horizonte, Minas Gerais. A semi-structured script was used. Data were analyzed through discourse analysis in a Foucaultian perspective. Results: three categories were developed - Professional Identity: self-recognition in the profession; Discipline: individualizing attitudes or collective need?; and Circularity of knowledge and power in the constitution of daily practices. Final considerations: the identity, discipline and circulation of power are connected in a continuous movement of subjectivation of the subject, which, in turn, uses discourse as a persuasion strategy to modify the position taken over in different situations thereby causing the circulation of power.

A Methodological and Practical Guide to Study Peripheral Voices in Qualitative Research

“…They avoided any kind of responsibility in the processes of change aimed at improvement, using arguments such as “their day to day is theirs, not mine” or that “this is your business”. These findings are supported by ample literature which demonstrates the power of physicians over allied health professionals and in the health system as a whole (Mattar E Silva et al, 2020; Reeves et al, 2008; Willis, 2020).…”

Biographical and Relational Professional Identity of the Nurse Manager

“…It is inferred that such a view comes from the corporate bond that she had with the health institution. The sphere of power in professional performance grants the individual social articulations based on decision-making processes, being a product manifested because of the decentralization of competencies 15 .…”

Identidade Profissional Biográfica E Relacional Da Enfermeira Gestora

“…Infere-se que tal visão advém do vínculo Societário que ela tinha para com a instituição de saúde. A esfera do poder na atuação profissional concede ao indivíduo articulações sociais pautadas nos processos decisórios, sendo um produto manifestado em decorrência da descentralização das competências 15 .…”