Qualitative comparative analysis: justifying a neo-configurational approach in management research

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to critically reflect and offer insights on how to justify the use of qualitative comparative analysis (QCA) as a research method for understanding the complexity of organizational phenomena, by applying the principles of the neo-configurational approach. Design/methodology/approach We present and critically examine three arguments regarding the use of QCA for management research. First, they discuss the need to assume configurational theories to build and empirically test a causal model of interest. Second, we explain how the three principles of causal complexity are assumed during the process of conducting QCA-based studies. Third, we elaborate on the importance of case knowledge when selecting the data for the analysis and when interpreting the results. Findings We argue that it is important to reflect on these arguments to have an appropriate research design. In the true spirit of the configurational approach, we contend that the three arguments presented are necessary; however, each argument is insufficient to warrant a QCA research design. Originality/value This paper contributes to management research by offering key arguments on how to justify the use of QCA-based studies in future research endeavors.

Bringing owners back on board: A review of the role of ownership type in board governance

“…Moreover, with the growing interest toward analyzing corporate governance through a configurational approach (Misangyi et al, 2017; Parente & Federo, 2019), future research would do well to explore how different ownership types jointly influence board governance. Given the divergent interests of different owners, it is crucial to have a more comprehensive understanding of how the presence of one ownership type could influence the motives and behaviors of other co‐owners.…”

“…And as firms develop into those with proven business models and steady revenues, they eventually attract institutional investors-including shareholder activists . Taken as a whole, rather than being domi- Moreover, with the growing interest toward analyzing corporate governance through a configurational approach (Misangyi et al, 2017;Parente & Federo, 2019), future research would do well to explore how different ownership types jointly influence board governance.…”

Research methods in management: advances and applications

“…The third qualitative article, written by Parente and Federo (2019), proposes a critical reflection on the use of qualitative comparative analysis (QCA) as a research method for understanding the complexity of organizational phenomena. The authors present three arguments regarding the use of QCA for management research.…”

Non‐financial strategy disclosure and environmental, social and governance score: Insight from a configurational approach

“…), and the disclosure occurrence presents the number of items in a checklist or disclosure index including least some disclosures. We would like to propose a combination of measures based on both the volume/quantity and diversity/quality of disclosure, obtained from a configurational approach (Furnari et al, 2020;Misangyi et al, 2017;Parente & Federo, 2019). This can be an appropriate approach since it allows the integration of different types of measurement in the holistic framework.…”