The phenyl cation is known to have two lowenergy minima, corresponding to 1 A 1 and 3 B 1 states, the ®rst of which is more stable by ca. 25 kcal/mol. The minimum energy crossing point between these two surfaces, located at various levels including a hybrid method ®rst described here, lies just above the minimum of the triplet, 0.12 kcal/mol at the CCSD(T)/cc-pVDZ// B3LYP/SV level, and there is signi®cant spin-orbit coupling between the surfaces at this point. On the basis of these results, the lifetime of the triplet is expected to be very short.
The cationic (C2H4)M+
complexes (M = Cu, Ag, and Au) have been examined by different ab
initio molecular
orbital, density functional (DFT), and density
functional/Hartree−Fock (DFT/HF) hybrid methods using
relativistic effective core potentials and a quasi-relativistic
approach to account for relativistic effects. For
(C2H4)Au+ a substantial
relativistic stabilization is observed, such that the computed binding
energies are
almost twice as high than for
(C2H4)Ag+ and still
significantly higher than for
(C2H4)Cu+. Structural
features
and energetics obtained at the various computational levels, although
they differ significantly in their
computational demands, are in satisfying agreement with each other,
adding to the level of confidence that
can be attributed to the computationally economic DFT and DFT/HF hybrid
methods. In order to determine
the nature of the bonding in these
(C2H4)M+ complexes, an
energy decomposition scheme is applied to the
DFT results. For all three metal cations, the interaction with
ethylene shows large covalent contributions.
The major part of the covalent terms stems from σ-donor
contribution from the ligand to the metal, whereas
π-acceptor bonding (back-bonding) is less important. An
atoms-in-molecules (AIM) analysis of the charge
density distribution reveals cyclic structures for
(C2H4)Au+ and
(C2H4)Cu+, whereas
(C2H4)Ag+ is
T-shaped.
The potential energy surface (PES) corresponding to the reaction
of the iron cation with ethane, which represents
a prototype of the activation of C−C and C−H bonds in alkanes by
transition metal cations, has been
investigated employing the recently suggested hybrid density functional
theory/Hartree−Fock method (B3LYP)
combined with reasonably large one-particle basis sets. The
performance of this computational approach has
been calibrated against experimentally known Fe+−R
binding energies of fragments R relevant to the
[Fe,C2,H6]+ PES and against the
relative energies of the possible exit channels. Both the C−C
and C−H
bond activation branches of the PES are characterized by a low barrier
for the first step, the insertion of the
iron cation into a C−C and C−H bond, respectively. Rate
determining are the second steps which in the
C−C bond activation branch corresponds to an [1,3]-H shift leading
to a complex between FeCH2
+
and
methane. Along the C−H activation reaction coordinate, no
transition state corresponding to a β-hydrogen
shift resulting in a dihydrido species could be located, even though
such a step has been often postulated.
The decisive step is rather a concerted saddle point connecting
the C−H inserted species directly with a
complex of Fe+ with molecular hydrogen and ethylene.
The mechanistic scenario provided by our calculations
is in concert with all experimental information and allows for the
first time a detailed and consistent view on
the mechanistic details of this import reaction sequence. It
further demonstrates the usefulness of the B3LYP
approach for describing even complex electronic situations such as
present in open-shell transition metal
compounds.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.