This study compares a stack machine, the Harris RTX 2000, a RISC machine, the Sun 4/SPARC, and a CISC machine, the Sun3/M68020. An attempt is made to compare the generic features of each machine which are characteristic of their architectural classes as opposed to being characteristic of the individual machine only. Performance is compared based on execution of the Stanford Integer Benchmark series (12) and on interrupt response characteristics. The data indicates that, for these benchmarks, the RTX stack architecture approaches or exceeds the SPARC machine performance for such measures as total execution cycles required, clock cycles per instruction, native MIPS, static code size, and dynamic instruction count. The 68020 machine is by far the slowest of the three. When scaled to account for disparities in process technology, the RTX 2000 is as fast as (or faster than) the SPARC in actual program execution time, and it has a smaller code size.
This study compares a stack machine, the Harris RTX 2000, a RISC machine, the Sun 4/SPARC, and a CISC machine, the Sun3/M68020 for real-time applications. An attempt is made to compare the generic features of each machine which are characteristic of their architectural classes as opposed to being characteristic of the individual machine only. Performance is compared based on execution of the Stanford Integer Benchmark series and on interrupt response characteristics. A simple Real-Time Performance BenchMark which integrates raw compute power and interrupt response is proposed, then used to estimate the real-time performance of the machines. It is shown that the RTX 2000 outperforms the others for applications which have a very large number of interrupts per second, confirming that stack architectures should perform well in real-time applications such as high-speed computer communication systems. For less interrupt intensive applications, the Sun 4 SPARC performs better.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.