Jvarely satisfied with a mere reinterpretation of "historical facts,*' reflective historical scholarship interacts with past and contemporary points of view. The recent book by Bengt Hoffman' illustrates this point. In his reexamination of Luther and the mystical, Hoffman attempts to revise prevailing interpretations in the light of the "contemporary revolt against reason'* and the rediscovery of "human transcendence** in "charismatic renewal.** The effort is not without merit. The majority of German Luther scholars for once escape the charge of rolling their eyeballs and engaging in nonsensical God-talk! Indeed, much of Hoffman*s energy is directed against the influence of rationalismscholastic and scientific^-on previous historiography. On his part, Hoffman attempts to illustrate that Luther's theological insights were rooted in the mystical experience of the numinous. He concludes that in spite of a different "nomenclature** Luther and his mystical predecessors, John Tauler and the author of the Theologia Deutsch, reckoned with a similar substantive connection between the human and the divine. In the experience of mystical union or reunion the believer is reborn, while God saves "that which is part of him in fundamental structure." In this context, Luther*s crucial understanding of the sinner*s standing before God, simul instus et peccator, becomes explicable as a simultaneous experience of mystical anguish and ecstasy. No less provocative is Hoffman's reappraisal of what in times past were considered Luther's embarrassingly sharp sensitivities for "para-normal appearances.' ' However, the relationship of apparitions of evU, in the form of black sows or dogs, to mysticism proper is not entirely clear. In Hoffman's account, Luther emerges as a charismatic faith healer, a sensitive psychic blessed with revelations of a "clairaudical and clairvoyant nature" who, through "the psychic force of faith," had become part of a "supernatural power field" with "access to the integrating center of the cosmosthe power center that makes cosmos one, the sun which is Christ." This reinterpretation of Luther into a charismatic heliocentrist need not distract from the better parts of Hoffman*s work. Certainly Hoffman must 80 / Renaissance and Reformation be applauded for attempting to shake ingrained preconceptions. If accepted, his findings would not only revise the traditional picture of Luther's relationship to mysticism but also force a reinterpretation on the broader historiography that has found a fruitful heuristic device in mysticism for differentiating between Luther and the radical wing of the Reformation. Unfortunately, with regard to the latter, Hoffman falls back on traditional categories. The radicals are castigated as 5c/z warmer appealing to subjective emotions. However, given Hoffman's own presuppositions, a distinction between true and false subjectivism becomes problematic. Hoffman appears innocent of the fact that the so-called Schwarmer were more consistent applicants of mystical assumptions to problems rais...
Book Reviews / Comptes rendus / 77 recouverte d'une casaque tout aussi sophistiquée évoquant le prestige du prince, à la fois "homme et bête" d'après Machiavel, et auquel les décorations emblématiques, imprégnées de réminiscences antiques confèrent une dimension mythique. Cette influence de l'Antiquité, confirmée par quelques illustrations, est également mise en évidence par Martine Vasselin, ainsi que le rôle intermédiaire joué par la Renaissance italienne: gravures d'ouvrages historiques, portraits, décors des résidences royales et des entrées princières s'efforcent d'harmoniser les exigences de ressemblance avec le modèle contemporain et la distanciation résultant du recours à l'antique, qui atteint son degré superlatif dans le trophée, substitut de l'image du guerrier. Jean Jacquart et Gabriel-André Pérouse, l'un historien, l'autre littéraire, ont apporté chacun leurs conclusions respectives à cette évocation très variée de l'homme de guerre, soldat, capitaine ou prince. Voyage dans le temps, du treizième au dix-septième siècle, voyage dans l'espace aussi: la matière était ample et peu d'aspects du problème ont été laissés dans l'ombre. Ni l'idéalisme humaniste, ni l'embellissement artistique ou l'affabulation littéraire n'ont masqué l'omniprésence de la guerre étrangère ou civile et de son cortège de violences, accrues en ce siècle de la Renaissance par le choc des idéologies et les perfectionnements techniques. ETIENNE VAUCHERET, Université de Pau Werner O. Packull. Hutterite Beginnings. Communitarian Experiments During the Reformation. BaUimore and London: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1995. Pp. xi, 440. Hutterite Beginnings is much more than just a chronicle of the early years of the Hutterites. Instead, Packull sets out to narrate the early history of the Hutterites, and of Moravian Anabaptism more generally, with close attention to its political, social and religious milieu. Part I of the book examines the conditions in Moravia which
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.
customersupport@researchsolutions.com
10624 S. Eastern Ave., Ste. A-614
Henderson, NV 89052, USA
Copyright © 2024 scite LLC. All rights reserved.
Made with 💙 for researchers
Part of the Research Solutions Family.