Fifteen centers for orthopaedic treatment of the foot and ankle participated in a prospective randomized trial to compare several nonoperative treatments for proximal plantar fasciitis (heel pain syndrome). Included were 236 patients (160 women and 76 men) who were 16 years of age or older. Most reported duration of symptoms of 6 months or less. Patients with systemic disease, significant musculoskeletal complaints, sciatica, or local nerve entrapment were excluded. We randomized patients prospectively into five different treatment groups. All groups performed Achilles tendon- and plantar fascia-stretching in a similar manner. One group was treated with stretching only. The other four groups stretched and used one of four different shoe inserts, including a silicone heel pad, a felt pad, a rubber heel cup, or a custom-made polypropylene orthotic device. Patients were reevaluated after 8 weeks of treatment. The percentages improved in each group were: (1) silicone insert, 95%; (2) rubber insert, 88%; (3) felt insert, 81%; (4)stretching only, 72%; and (5) custom orthosis, 68%. Combining all the patients who used a prefabricated insert, we found that their improvement rates were higher than those assigned to stretching only (P = 0.022) and those who stretched and used a custom orthosis (P = 0.0074). We conclude that, when used in conjunction with a stretching program, a prefabricated shoe insert is more likely to produce improvement in symptoms as part of the initial treatment of proximal plantar fasciitis than a custom polypropylene orthotic device.

Level III, retrospective comparative case series.

Level III, retrospective cohort study.

Dorsal cheilectomy of the hallux metatarsophalangeal (MTP) joint through a medial approach can effectively provide long-term relief of pain and improve function in symptomatic mild-to-moderate hallux rigidus, despite progression of generalized first MTP joint arthritic degeneration and/or loss of motion. Fifty-seven patients (75 feet) with arthritis of the first MTP joint underwent dorsal cheilectomy through a medial approach for hallux rigidus failing nonoperative management. Excision of the dorsal articular surface of the first metatarsal head and dorsal osteophytes was performed through a medial approach that also allowed for plantar capsular release and removal of lateral osteophytes. Minimum follow-up was 3 years (average, 63 months; range, 37-92 months). Fifty-two patients (68 feet) returned for clinical and radiographic evaluation. American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society Hallux Rating scores improved from a preoperative average of 45 to 85 points at follow-up. Average dorsiflexion improved from 19 degrees to 39 degrees, and the average range of motion improved from 34 degrees to 64 degrees. Preoperative radiographic grade of arthritic degeneration was grade I in 17 feet, grade II in 39 feet, and grade III in 12 feet; at follow-up, the radiographic grade was grade I in 2 feet, grade II in 26 feet, and grade III in 40 feet. Thirty-two feet worsened one grade, 6 feet worsened two grades, and 28 feet demonstrated no change (12 of 28 were grade III, preoperatively). A dorsal spur recurred in 21 feet, 9 of which were symptomatic. Complications included two superficial wound infections and four transient paresthesias of the hallux, all of which resolved uneventfully.

In recent years there has been an increased interest in the treatment of acquired pes planus. The breakdown of the medial longitudinal arch is most often seen at the talonaviculocalcaneal articulation. This suggests a relationship between the ligamentous complex at this articulation and acquired pes planus. This study was undertaken to gain a better understanding of the gross, histologic, and microvascular anatomy, as well as the biomechanics of the ligamentous structures surrounding the talonaviculocalcaneal articulation. Cadaver dissections of 38 fresh-frozen feet were performed. Detailed descriptions of the gross anatomy of the superomedial calcaneonavicular ligament, inferior calcaneonavicular ligament, and the superficial deltoid ligament were recorded. Their relationships to the posterior tibialis tendon and to the bones of the talonaviculocalcaneal articulation are described. The histology and microvascularity of these structures were also studied. Preliminary biomechanical testing was performed. It was found there are two definitive anatomic structures that are commonly called the spring ligament: the superomedial calcaneonavicular ligament (SMCN) and the inferior calcaneonavicular ligament (ICN). The SMCN ligament was found to have histologic properties that suggest significant load bearing. The histology of the ICN ligament suggests a pure tensile load function. The deltoid ligament and the posterior tibialis tendon had direct attachments to the SMCN ligament in all specimens. An articular facet composed of fibrocartilage was found in each SMCN ligament specimen. The microvascular structures showed an avascular articular facet present in the ligament. The biomechanical testing showed that the SMCN ligament and ICN ligament had strength similar to ankle ligaments. This study suggests this "spring ligament complex" has more of a "sling" function for the talar head. It is hoped that the better understanding of this region will add to our understanding of the etiology of pes planus and possible treatment alternatives.