Twenty-one knees with acutely injured anterior cruciate ligaments were reconstructed with patellar tendon autografts. Eight of the knees had concomitant medial ligament injuries that were not addressed surgically. Follow-up evaluation (average, 25 months) included computed tomography measurements to analyze transverse-plane laxity in both translation and rotation. These measurements were performed with the patient's leg in a load cell device that stabilizes the distal femur and applies known anterior translational force to the proximal tibia at approximately 20 degrees of flexion. A torque apparatus was used to apply internal and external rotational torque to the leg. Images of the tibial plateau in neutral, internal, and external rotation were performed, with and without an anterior translational force. Both knees of each patient were tested and categorized as group I (anterior cruciate ligament-reconstructed) or group II (uninjured). Translation as measured by computed tomography averaged 1 mm side-to-side difference. Internal rotation averaged 8.7 degrees in group I knees and 10.8 degrees in group II knees. External rotation averaged 9.1 degrees in group I knees and 7.4 degrees in group II knees. The eight knees with concomitant medial ligament injuries were analyzed separately; external rotation without anterior load in group I was 9.5 degrees, compared with 5 degrees in group II. This difference was significant (P < 0.01).
Shortening of the fibula after fracture is common and often difficult to appreciate. Loss of lateral malleolar anatomy causes significant biomechanical changes in the ankle and correlates with poor clinical results. We studied angular measurements of distal fibular length to serve as a guide for assessing fibular reduction after ankle fracture. Mortise view X-rays of 50 normal ankles from 25 healthy volunteers were obtained. The average talocrural angle measured 78.5 degrees. However, individual variation was high with values ranging from 75 to 86 degrees. Comparing contralateral ankles demonstrated an average difference of 1.3 degrees (range 0 to 4 degrees). A new, simpler bimalleolar angle was devised which compares the long axis of the fibula with a line drawn between the tips of the malleoli. The average bimalleolar angle measured 77.8 degrees (range 72 to 86 degrees). The contralateral difference averaged 1.2 degrees (range 0 to 3 degrees). This angle was simpler to use and more reproducible. Angular measurements were tolerant of usual radiographic techniques. Internal or external rotation of the ankle up to 5 degrees caused an insignificant change in the angular measurements. One degree change in the talocrural or bimalleolar angle was found to correspond with a 1 mm change in fibular length for the average ankle, calculated radiographically and confirmed in a cadaver study. Abnormal fibular shortening is detected with an angular difference between injured and contralateral sides of 3.0 degrees using the talocrural angle or 2.5 degrees using the bimalleolar angle (95% confidence limits). Thus, a 2.5 to 3.0 degrees contralateral difference should serve as a minimum value required to direct a change in therapy.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.