The addictive potential of opioids may be related to their differential ability to induce G protein signaling and endocytosis. We compared the ability of 20 ligands (sampled from the main chemical classes of opioids) to promote the association of and ␦ receptors with G protein or ␤-arrestin 2. Receptor-arrestin binding was monitored by bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET) in intact cells, where pertussis toxin experiments indicated that the interaction was minimally affected by receptor signaling. To assess receptor-G protein coupling without competition from arrestins, we employed a cell-free BRET assay using membranes isolated from cells expressing luminescent receptors and fluorescent G␤ 1 . In this system, the agonistinduced enhancement of BRET (indicating shortening of distance between the two proteins) was G␣-mediated (as shown by sensitivity to pertussis toxin and guanine nucleotides) and yielded data consistent with the known pharmacology of the ligands. We found marked differences of efficacy for G protein and arrestin, with a pattern suggesting more restrictive structural requirements for arrestin efficacy. The analysis of such differences identified a subset of structures showing a marked discrepancy between efficacies for G protein and arrestin. Addictive opiates like morphine and oxymorphone exhibited large differences both at ␦ and receptors. Thus, they were effective agonists for G protein coupling but acted as competitive enkephalins antagonists (␦) or partial agonists () for arrestin. This arrestin-selective antagonism resulted in inhibition of short and long term events mediated by arrestin, such as rapid receptor internalization and down-regulation.Physiological agonists are usually equally efficient in promoting the interaction of receptors with G protein and arrestin, but manmade analogues can show divergent molecular efficacies for the two transducers (1, 2). This phenomenon, often addressed with a pictorial terminology (3-5), has attracted great interest and if better understood might lead to new types of drugs.The differential efficacy of opioids for G protein and arrestin interactions is also important in the mechanism of opiate addiction. As reported earlier, the addictive opiate morphine cannot induce and actually blocks desensitization and G protein uncoupling of ␦-opioid receptors (DOPR) 2 in neuroblastoma or in transfected cells (6, 7). Subsequent work shows that morphine is a poor inducer of rapid arrestin-dependent endocytosis for both ␦ and (MOPR) receptors (8 -11), although one exception is in striatum neurons with high levels of G protein receptor kinases (12).Two theories predict a relation between lack of endocytosis and the addiction liability of opioids, but the proposed explanations are radically different. One sees rapid endocytosis as a means to quench receptor signaling. Thus, the abnormally sustained signaling pattern produced by a drug that cannot internalize the receptor would promote post-receptor compensatory mechanisms, which may be responsible for the...

Discovering biased agonists requires a method that can reliably distinguish the bias in signalling due to unbalanced activation of diverse transduction proteins from that of differential amplification inherent to the system being studied, which invariably results from the non-linear nature of biological signalling networks and their measurement. We have systematically compared the performance of seven methods of bias diagnostics, all of which are based on the analysis of concentration-response curves of ligands according to classical receptor theory. We computed bias factors for a number of β-adrenergic agonists by comparing BRET assays of receptor-transducer interactions with Gs, Gi and arrestin. Using the same ligands, we also compared responses at signalling steps originated from the same receptor-transducer interaction, among which no biased efficacy is theoretically possible. In either case, we found a high level of false positive results and a general lack of correlation among methods. Altogether this analysis shows that all tested methods, including some of the most widely used in the literature, fail to distinguish true ligand bias from “system bias” with confidence. We also propose two novel semi quantitative methods of bias diagnostics that appear to be more robust and reliable than currently available strategies.

IntroductionOpioid receptors are currently classified as Mu (μ), Delta (δ), Kappa (κ) plus the opioid related nociceptin/orphanin FQ (N/OFQ) peptide receptor (NOP). Despite compelling evidence for interactions and benefits of targeting more than one receptor type in producing analgesia, clinical ligands are Mu agonists. In this study we have designed a Mu-NOP agonist named DeNo. The Mu agonist component is provided by dermorphin, a peptide isolated from the skin of Phyllomedusa frogs and the NOP component by the endogenous agonist N/OFQ.MethodsWe have assessed receptor binding profile of DeNo and compared with dermorphin and N/OFQ. In a series of functional screens we have assessed the ability to (i) increase Ca2+ in cells coexpressing recombinant receptors and a the chimeric protein Gαqi5, (ii) stimulate the binding of GTPγ[35S], (iii) inhibit cAMP formation, (iv) activate MAPKinase, (v) stimulate receptor-G protein and arrestin interaction using BRET, (vi) electrically stimulated guinea pig ileum (gpI) assay and (vii) ability to produce analgesia via the intrathecal route in rats.ResultsDeNo bound to Mu (pKi; 9.55) and NOP (pKi; 10.22) and with reasonable selectivity. This translated to increased Ca2+ in Gαqi5 expressing cells (pEC50 Mu 7.17; NOP 9.69), increased binding of GTPγ[35S] (pEC50 Mu 7.70; NOP 9.50) and receptor-G protein interaction in BRET (pEC50 Mu 8.01; NOP 9.02). cAMP formation was inhibited and arrestin was activated (pEC50 Mu 6.36; NOP 8.19). For MAPK DeNo activated p38 and ERK1/2 at Mu but only ERK1/2 at NOP. In the gpI DeNO inhibited electrically-evoked contractions (pEC50 8.63) that was sensitive to both Mu and NOP antagonists. DeNo was antinociceptive in rats.ConclusionCollectively these data validate the strategy used to create a novel bivalent Mu-NOP peptide agonist by combining dermorphin (Mu) and N/OFQ (NOP). This molecule behaves essentially as the parent compounds in vitro. In the antonocicoeptive assays employed in this study DeNo displays only weak antinociceptive properties.

Background: Native subtypes of G protein-coupled receptors (GPCR) show different levels of constitutive activation. Results: Using a BRET assay to detect receptor-G protein complexes, we find that constitutive activation causes a uniform reduction of the apparent efficacy of all ligands. Conclusion: An intramolecular energy barrier separates constitutive from ligand-regulated activation. Significance: The data suggest that GPCR activation involves both cooperative and anticooperative components.

Nephrogenic syndrome of inappropriate antidiuresis (NSIAD) is a recently identified chromosome X-linked disease associated with gain-of-function mutations of the V2 vasopressin receptor (V2R), a G-protein-coupled receptor. It is characterized by inability to excrete a free water load, hyponatremia, and undetectable vasopressin-circulating levels. Hyponatremia can be quite severe in affected male children. To gain a deeper insight into the functional properties of the V2R active mutants and how they might translate into the pathological outcome of NSIAD, in this study, we have expressed the wild-type V2R and three constitutively active V2R mutants associated with NSIAD (R137L, R137C, and the F229V) in MCD4 cells, a cell line derived from renal mouse collecting duct, stably expressing the vasopressin-sensitive water channel aquaporin-2 (AQP2). Our findings indicate that in cells expressing each active mutant, AQP2 was constitutively localized to the apical plasma membrane in the absence of vasopressin stimulation. In line with these observations, under basal conditions, osmotic water permeability in cells expressing the constitutively active mutants was significantly higher compared to that of cells expressing the wild-type V2R. Our findings demonstrate a direct link between activating mutations of the V2R and the perturbation of water balance in NSIAD. In addition, this study provides a useful cell-based assay system to assess the functional consequences of newly discovered activating mutations of the V2R on water permeability in kidney cells and to screen the effect of drugs on the mutated receptors.