A direct measurement of the He(y, po) reaction was performed using 34 MeV end-point bremsstrahlung photons. Photoprotons were simultaneously detected at nine angles. The magnitude of the deduced cross section is at variance with the results from recent experiments but is in perfect agreement with the previously recommended values. Consequently, as yet no definite conclusion can be drawn about the validity of charge symmetry of the nuclear force.The question of the absolute magnitude of the "He(y, po) reaction continues to raise a lot of attention and debate. This reaction is of particular importance since a direct comparison of the (y,p ) and (y, n ) cross sections for the self-conjugate nucleus He yields valuable information [1] concerning the concept of charge symmetry of the nuclear force, which is considered to be one of its basic characteristics. If this property is valid, the ratio R of these two cross sections should be close to unity in the giant dipole resonance (GDR) region [2). Deviations from this value mainly arise from Coulomb e8'ects, but realistic calculations raise the value of R only to about 1.1 [2,3].However, as yet the experimental situation is not clear.In 1983, a balanced review by Calarco et al. [2,4] of all available experimental total cross section data for both the (y, p) and (y, n ) reactions yielded surprising results.In this evaluation much more credibility was given to the (p, y) capture data as compared to the direct (y, p) values, mainly because the latter ones were obtained with a bremsstrahlung beam (continuous spectrum) and only the proton was detected. Calarco et aI. concluded that the ratio R showed a maximum around 25 MeV, equaling a value of 1.7+0.2, its explanation requiring an extremely large amount of isospin mixing between the excited states of He and thus inconsistent with charge symmetry. Of particular interest here is the fact that Calarco recommends a (y,p ) cross section which reaches 1.85+0.12 mb at 26 MeV, gradually decreasing to about 1.3 mb at 34 MeV. The magnitude and behavior of such cross section could be reasonably well theoretically described by Wachter et al. [3]. However, these same authors concluded that, relying on a selected set of (y, n) data, the di8'erences between the cross sections for both mirror channels did not require any isospin violating nuclear force. Nevertheless, the (y, p ) cross section as recommended by Calarco was not confirmed by subsequent experiments. Bernabei et al. [5] reported a direct measurement of the absolute total "He(y, p) cross section in the 28.6 -58.1 MeV energy interval, using a quasimonoenergetic photon fiux and a nearly 4m. proton detector. These (y,p) cross section results had about the same magnitude as Calarco's suggested (y, n) cross section, leading to a mean value of R =1.01+0.06. A measurement [6] of the inverse H(p, y) He process in the energy region corresponding to photon energies between 21.3 and 31.1 MeV confirmed the latter data set. These new experimental (y,p) cross sections could be extremely well re...
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.
hi@scite.ai
10624 S. Eastern Ave., Ste. A-614
Henderson, NV 89052, USA
Copyright © 2024 scite LLC. All rights reserved.
Made with 💙 for researchers
Part of the Research Solutions Family.