Many recently described Phytophthora species detected using high‐throughput sequencing have never been isolated into culture. NARH is a commonly used isolation medium containing cornmeal agar with nystatin 22.72 ppm, ampicillin 100 ppm, rifampicin 10 ppm, and hymexazol 50 ppm. We investigated whether the antimicrobial compounds in this medium selectively inhibit growth of some Phytophthora species. Growth of 10 Phytophthora species from 10 Phytophthora clades was tested in NARH medium with antimicrobials in a range of concentrations, singly and in combination: nystatin 12.5–100 ppm, ampicillin 62.5–500 ppm, rifampicin 5–40 ppm, hymexazol 12.5–100 ppm and in addition, chloramphenicol 5–40 ppm. Two combinations of antimicrobials that supported good growth of the greatest number of species were selected: (a) nystatin 12.5 ppm, ampicillin 250 ppm, rifampicin 10 ppm, and hymexazol 12.5 ppm, and (b) these compounds with the addition of chloramphenicol 5 ppm. Subsequently the growth of 47 Phytophthora species from all clades was tested in media with these two combinations and standard NARH, both in aseptic culture and in plates with leaf baits infected from soils known to be infested with Phytophthora. Although growth of some Phytophthora species was better with the new combinations of antimicrobials in aseptic culture, suppression of competing microorganisms was best in standard NARH. Sensitivity to the NARH antimicrobials is not the reason for the difficulty or failure of isolating many species detected using high‐throughput sequencing. NARH is a robust and appropriate medium for isolation of Phytophthora species from all clades.
This review assesses possible reasons for the discrepancy between the high numbers of Phytophthora species and putative new species isolated from environmental samples using metabarcoding, compared with the low number cultured and identified through bating. Molecular protocols are unlikely to result in high numbers of false positives, except that variants in young hybrid species may be incorrectly identified as different species. Baiting conditions favour parasitic species that are fast to sporulate, able to infect a range of bait species, achieve infection with a low number of zoospores, and fast-growing on selective agar. Species may not be isolated because they are slow-growing saprophytes and slow to sporulate when baited. Changes to protocols that might result in the isolation of more species include changes in the timing of exposure of baits, inclusions of dead baits, reducing potential competition from fast-growing species by baiting only small volumes of soil, and isolation on media without antimicrobials. However, the species not isolated may have growth traits precluding easy isolation, such as host specificity or obligate biotroph lifestyle.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.