A water-soluble cubic coordination cage (H w) has been prepared, which is isostructural with a previously reported organic-soluble cage (H) apart from the hydroxy groups on the external surface which render it water-soluble. These two cages act as hosts for small organic molecules which bind via a combination of (i) hydrogen-bonding interactions with specific sites on the internal surface of the cages; (ii) nonpolar interactions such as aromatic and van der Waals interactions between aromatic rings in the guest and the cage internal surface; and (iii) solvophobic interactions. By comparing DG values for guest binding in water (using H w) and MeCN (using H), and using pairs of related guests that differ in the presence or absence of an aromatic ring substituent, it is possible to construct thermodynamic cycles that allow quantification of the solvophobic contribution to binding. Specifically, this is the difference between the solvophobic contributions to DG in water and MeCN associated with desolvation of both guest and the internal surface of the cage when complexation occurs. A highly consistent value of ca. À10 kJ mol À1 is determined for this solvophobic contribution to DG associated with the aromatic ring in water compared to MeCN, which correlates very well with what would be expected based on the free energy changes associated with transfer of toluene from MeCN to water. Thus, all three contributions to guest binding listed above can be separately quantified. The ability to prepare related pairs of guests with the presence or absence of a wide range of substituents provides a potentially general way to quantify the solvophobic contributions to guest binding of these substituents.
Size and shape criteria for guest binding inside the cavity of an octanuclear cubic coordination cage in water have been established using a new fluorescence displacement assay to quantify guest binding. For aliphatic cyclic ketones of increasing size (from C5 to C11), there is a linear relationship between ΔG for guest binding and the guest's surface area: the change in ΔG for binding is 0.3 kJ mol(-1) Å(-2), corresponding to 5 kJ mol(-1) for each additional CH2 group in the guest, in good agreement with expectations based on hydrophobic desolvation. The highest association constant is K = 1.2 × 10(6) M(-1) for cycloundecanone, whose volume is approximately 50% of the cavity volume; for larger C12 and C13 cyclic ketones, the association constant progressively decreases as the guests become too large. For a series of C10 aliphatic ketones differing in shape but not size, ΔG for guest binding showed no correlation with surface area. These guests are close to the volume limit of the cavity (cf. Rebek's 55% rule), so the association constant is sensitive to shape complementarity, with small changes in guest structure resulting in large changes in binding affinity. The most flexible members of this series (linear aliphatic ketones) did not bind, whereas the more preorganized cyclic ketones all have association constants of 10(4)-10(5) M(-1). A crystal structure of the cage·cycloundecanone complex shows that the guest carbonyl oxygen is directed into a binding pocket defined by a convergent set of CH groups, which act as weak hydrogen-bond donors, and also shows close contacts between the exterior surface of the disc-shaped guest and the interior surface of the pseudospherical cage cavity despite the slight mismatch in shape.
The host-guest chemistry of the octanuclear cubic coordination cage [Co(8)L(12)](16+) (where L is a bridging ligand containing two chelating pyrazolyl-pyridine units connected to a central naphthalene-1,5-diyl spacer via methylene "hinges") has been investigated in detail by (1)H NMR spectroscopy. The cage encloses a cavity of volume of ca. 400 Å(3), which is accessible through 4 Å diameter portals in the centers of the cube faces. The paramagnetism of the cage eliminates overlap of NMR signals by dispersing them over a range of ca. 200 ppm, making changes of specific signals easy to observe, and also results in large complexation-induced shifts of bound guests. The cage, in CD(3)CN solution, acts as a remarkably size- and shape-selective host for small organic guests such as coumarin (K = 78 M(-1)) and other bicyclic molecules of comparable size and shape such as isoquinoline-N-oxide (K = 2100 M(-1)). Binding arises from two independent recognition elements, which have been separately quantified. These are (i) a polar component arising from interaction of the H-bond accepting O atom of the guest with a convergent group of CH protons inside the cavity that lie close to a fac tris-chelate metal center and are therefore in a region of high electrostatic potential; and (ii) an additional component arising from the second aromatic ring (aromatic/van der Waals interactions with the interior surface of the cage and/or solvophobic interactions). The strength of the first component varies linearly with the H-bond-accepting ability of the guest; the second component is fixed at approximately 10 kJ mol(-1). We have also used (1)H-(1)H exchange spectroscopy (EXSY) experiments to analyze semiquantitatively two distinct dynamic processes, viz. movement of the guest into and out of the cavity and tumbling of the guest inside the host cavity. Depending on the size of the guest and the position of substituents, the rates of these processes can vary substantially, and the rates of processes that afford observable cross-peaks in EXSY spectra (e.g., between free and bound guest in some cases; between different conformers of a specific host·guest complex in others) can be narrowed down to a specific time window. Overall, the paramagnetism of the host cage has allowed an exceptionally detailed analysis of the kinetics and thermodynamics of its host-guest behavior.
Binding of organic guests containing acidic or basic groups inside a water-soluble coordination cage host shows strong pH dependence.
The protein/ligand docking programme ‘GOLD’ can be used to identify new strongly-binding guests for a synthetic coordination cage host.
The synthesis of a family of zinc porphyrins and pyridine ligands equipped with peripheral H-bonding functionality has provided access to a wide range of closely related supramolecular complexes featuring between zero and four intramolecular H-bonds. An automated UV/vis titration system was used to characterize 120 different complexes, and these data were used to construct a large of number of different chemical double mutant cycles to quantify the intramolecular H-bonding interactions. The results probe the quantitative structure-activity relationship that governs cooperativity in the assembly of complex molecular recognition interfaces. Specifically, variations in the chemical structures of the complexes have allowed us to change the supramolecular architecture, conformational flexibility, geometric complementarity, the number and nature of the H-bond interactions, and the overall stability of the complex. The free energy contributions from individual H-bonds are additive, and there is remarkably little variation with architecture in the effective molarity for the formation of intramolecular interactions. Intramolecular H-bonds are not observed in complexes where they are geometrically impossible, but there are no cases where excellent geometric complementarity leads to very high affinities. Similarly, changes in conformational flexibility seem to have limited impact on the values of effective molarity (EM). The major variation that was found for all of the 48 intramolecular interactions that were examined using double mutant cycles is that the values of EM for intramolecular carboxylate ester-phenol H-bonds (200 mM) are an order of magnitude larger than those found for phosphonate diester-phenol H-bonds (30 mM). The corresponding intermolecular phosphonate diester-phenol H-bonds are 2 orders of magnitude more stable than carboxylate ester-phenol H-bonds, and the large differences in EM may be due to some kind of compensation effect, where the stronger H-bond is harder to make, because it imposes tighter constraints on the geometry of the complex.
Chemical double mutant cycles have been used in conjunction with new H-bonding motifs for the quantification of chelate cooperativity in multiply H-bonded complexes. The double mutant cycle approach specifically deals with the effects of substituents, secondary interactions, and allosteric cooperativity on the free energy contributions from individual H-bond sites and allows dissection of the free energy contribution due to chelate cooperativity associated with the formation of intramolecular noncovalent interactions. Two different doubly H-bonded motifs were investigated in carbon tetrachloride, chloroform, 1,1,2,2-tetrachloroethane, and cyclohexane, and the results were similar in all cases, with effective molarities of 3-33 M for formation of intramolecular H-bonds. This corresponds to a free energy penalty of 3-9 kJ mol -1 for formation of a bimolecular complex in solution, which is consistent with previous estimates of 6 kJ mol -1 . This result can be used in conjunction with the H-bond parameters, R and β, to make a reasonable estimate of the stability constant for formation of a multiply H-bonded complex between two perfectly complementary partners, or to place an upper limit on the stability constant expected for a less complementary system.
The association constants for a family of 96 closely related zinc porphyrin-pyridine ligand complexes have been measured in two different solvents, toluene and 1,1,2,2-tetrachloroethane (TCE). The zinc porphyrin receptors are equipped with phenol side arms, which can form intramolecular H-bonds with ester or amide side arms on the pyridine ligands. These association constants were used to construct 64 chemical double mutant cycles, which measure the free energy contributions of intramolecular H-bonding interactions to the overall stability of the complexes. Measurement of association constants for the corresponding intermolecular H-bonding interactions allowed determination of the effective molarities (EM) for the intramolecular interactions. Comparison of ligands that feature amide H-bond acceptors and ester H-bonds at identical sites on the ligand framework show that the values of EM are practically identical. Similarly, the values of EM are practically identical in toluene and in TCE. However, comparison of two ligand series that differ by one degree of torsional freedom shows that the values of EM for the flexible ligands are an order of magnitude lower than for the corresponding rigid ligands. This observation holds for a range of different supramolecular architectures with different degrees of receptor-ligand complementarity and suggests that in general the cost of freezing a rotor in supramolecular complexes is of the order of 5 kJ/mol.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.
hi@scite.ai
10624 S. Eastern Ave., Ste. A-614
Henderson, NV 89052, USA
Copyright © 2024 scite LLC. All rights reserved.
Made with 💙 for researchers
Part of the Research Solutions Family.