The role of implicit and explicit negative feedback in first (Ll) and second (L2) language acquisition is contentious. The L2 studies to date, however, suggest that implicit negative feedback exists, is perceived by learners for what it is (i.e., noticed), and is used for development. As part of one of several continuing lines of research on this issue, two experiments were conducted to assess the relative utility of models and recasts in L2 Japanese and Spanish. Using a pretest, posttest, control group design, each study provided some evidence of the ability of adults to learn from implicit negative feedback, and, in one case, support for the notion that reactive implicit negative feedback (recasts) can be more effective than preemptive positive input (models) in achieving at least short-term improvements on a previously unknown L2 structure.
The role of implicit and explicit negative feedback in first (Ll) and second (L2) language acquisition is contentious. The L2 studies to date, however, suggest that implicit negative feedback exists, is perceived by learners for what it is (i.e., noticed), and is used for development. As part of one of several continuing lines of research on this issue, two experiments were conducted to assess the relative utility of models and recasts in L2 Japanese and Spanish. Using a pretest, posttest, control group design, each study provided some evidence of the ability of adults to learn from implicit negative feedback, and, in one case, support for the notion that reactive implicit negative feedback (recasts) can be more effective than preemptive positive input (models) in achieving at least short-term improvements on a previously unknown L2 structure.
In English, manner-of-motion verbs (walk, run) and directed motion
verbs (go) can appear with a prepositional phrase that expresses a goal (goal PP) as in John walked (ran, went) to school. In contrast, Japanese allows only directed motion
verbs to occur with a goal PP. Thus, English allows a wider range of motion verbs to occur with
goal PPs than Japanese does. Learnability considerations, then, lead me to hypothesize that
Japanese learners will learn manner-of-motion verbs with goal PPs in English from positive
evidence, whereas English learners will have difficulty learning that manner-of-motion verbs with
goal PPs are impossible in Japanese because nothing in the input will tell them so. Forty-two
intermediate Japanese learners of English and 21 advanced English learners of Japanese were
tested using a grammaticality judgment task with pictures. Results support this prediction and
provide a new piece of evidence for the previous findings indicating that L1 influence persists
when an argument structure in the L2 constitutes a subset of its counterpart in the L1.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.