Acid-base catalytic reaction, either in heterogeneous or homogeneous systems, is one of the most important chemical reactions that has provoked a wide variety of industrial catalytic processes for production of chemicals and petrochemicals over the past few decades. In view of the fact that the catalytic performances (e.g., activity, selectivity, and reaction mechanism) of acid-catalyzed reactions over acidic catalysts are mostly dictated by detailed acidic features, viz. type (Brønsted vs Lewis acidity), amount (concentration), strength, and local environments (location) of acid sites, information on and manipulation of their structure-activity correlation are crucial for optimization of catalytic performances as well as innovative design of novel effective catalysts. This review aims to summarize recent developments on acidity characterization of solid and liquid catalysts by means of experimental P nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy using phosphorus probe molecules such as trialkylphosphine (TMP) and trialkylphosphine oxides (RPO). In particular, correlations between the observed P chemical shifts (δP) of phosphorus (P)-containing probes and acidic strengths have been established in conjuction with density functional theory (DFT) calculations, rendering practical and reliable acidity scales for Brønsted and Lewis acidities at the atomic level. As illustrated for a variety of different solid and liquid acid systems, such as microporous zeolites, mesoporous molecular sieves, and metal oxides, the P NMR probe approaches were shown to provide important acid features of various catalysts, surpassing most conventional methods such as titration, pH measurement, Hammett acidity function, and some other commonly used physicochemical techniques, such as calorimetry, temperature-programmed desorption of ammonia (NH-TPD), Fourier transformed infrared (FT-IR), and H NMR spectroscopies.

A brief review is presented on acidity characterization of solid acid catalysts by means of solid-state phosphor-31 magic-angle-spinning nuclear magnetic resonance ((31)P MAS NMR) spectroscopy using phosphor-containing molecules as probes. It is emphasized that such a simple approach using (31)P MAS NMR of adsorbed phosphorous probe molecules, namely trimethylphosphine (TMP) and trialkylphosphine oxides (R(3)PO), represents a unique technique in providing detailed qualitative and quantitative features, viz. type, strength, distribution, and concentration of acid sites in solid acid catalysts. In particular, it will be shown that when applied with a proper choice of probe molecules with varied sizes and results obtained from elemental analysis, the amounts and locations (intracrystalline vs. extracrystalline) of different types (Brønsted vs. Lewis) of acid sites may be determined. In addition, by incorporating the NMR results with that obtained from theoretical density functional theory (DFT) calculations, correlations between the (31)P chemical shifts (δ(31)P) and acidic strengths of Brønsted and Lewis acid sites may also be derived, facilitating a suitable acidity scale for solid acid catalysts.

A new methodology is reported for concurrent qualitative and quantitative characterization of internal and external acid sites in zeolitic catalysts. H-ZSM-5 zeolites with varied Si/Al ratios have been examined by solid-state 31 P MAS NMR using different adsorbed probe molecules, namely trimethylphosphine oxides (TMPO) and tributylphosphine oxide (TBPO), in conjunction with elemental analysis. Up to seven distinct 31 P resonance peaks at 86, 75, 67, 63, 53, 43, and 30 ppm were identified from the 31 P NMR spectra of adsorbed TMPO. The resonance peak at 30 ppm has never been observed previously and may be ascribed to mobile TMPO. The peak at 43 ppm is assigned to physisorbed TMPO. The rest of the peaks result from TMPOH + complexes at Brønsted sites with peaks at higher chemical shifts reflecting acid sites of higher strengths. 31 P NMR experiments, performed with TMPO and TBPO adsorbed on a mesoporous MCM-41 sample, respectively, provide further correlation of the internal and external acid sites. It is concluded that the peaks at 75 and 53 ppm arise exclusively from the internal Brønsted sites, whereas the peaks at 86, 67, and 63 ppm are associated with both internal and external acid sites. While the concentration and distribution of internal sites were found to increase with acid strengths, changing the Si/Al ratio of HZSM-5 has nearly no effect on the strength of the external acid sites.

No abstract

Solid acid materials with tunable structural and acidic properties are promising heterogeneous catalysts for manipulating and/or emulating the activity and selectivity of industrially important catalytic reactions. On the other hand, the performances of acid-catalyzed reactions are mostly dictated by the acidic features, namely, type (Brønsted vs Lewis acidity), amount, strength, and local environment of acid sites. The latter is relevant to their location (intra- vs extracrystalline), and possible confinement and Brønsted-Lewis acid synergy effects that may strongly affect the host-guest interactions, reaction mechanism, and shape selectivity of the catalytic system. This account aims to highlight some important applications of state-of-the-art solid-state NMR (SSNMR) techniques for exploring the structural and acidic properties of solid acid catalysts as well as their catalytic performances and relevant reaction pathway invoked. In addition, density functional theory (DFT) calculations may be exploited in conjunction with experimental SSNMR studies to verify the structure-activity correlations of the catalytic system at a microscopic scale. We describe in this Account the developments and applications of advanced ex situ and/or in situ SSNMR techniques, such as two-dimensional (2D) double-quantum magic-angle spinning (DQ MAS) homonuclear correlation spectroscopy for structural investigation of solid acids as well as study of their acidic properties. Moreover, the energies and electronic structures of the catalysts and detailed catalytic reaction processes, including the identification of reaction species, elucidation of reaction mechanism, and verification of structure-activity correlations, made available by DFT theoretical calculations were also discussed. Relevant discussions will focus primarily on results obtained from our laboratories in the past decade, including (i) quantitative and qualitative acidity characterization utilizing assorted probe molecules, (ii) probing the spatial proximity and synergy effect of acid sites, and (iii) influence of acid features and pore confinement effect on catalytic activity, transition-state stability, reaction pathway, and product selectivity of solid acid catalysts such as zeolites, metal oxides, and heteropolyacids. It is conclusive that a synergy of acidity (local effect) and pore confinement (environmental effect) tend to strongly dictate the formations of intermediates and transition states, hence, the reaction pathways and catalytic performance of solid acid catalysts. We hope that these information can provide additional insights toward our understanding in heterogeneous catalysis, especially the roles of structural and acidic properties on catalytic performances and reaction mechanism of acid-catalyzed systems, which should be beneficial for rational design of solid acid catalysts.

The origin of the exceptionally high activity of (B, Ag)-codoped TiO(2) catalysts under solar-light irradiation has been investigated by XPS and (11)B solid-state NMR spectroscopy in conjunction with density functional theory (DFT) calculations. XPS experimental results demonstrated that a portion of the dopant Ag (Ag(3+)) ions were implanted into the crystalline lattice of (B, Ag)-codoped TiO(2) and were in close proximity to the interstitial B (B(int.)) sites, forming [B(int.)-O-Ag] structural units. In situ XPS experiments were employed to follow the evolution of the chemical states of the B and Ag dopants during UV-vis irradiation. It was found that the [B(int.)-O-Ag] units could trap the photoinduced electron to form a unique intermediate structure in the (B, Ag)-codoped TiO(2) during the irradiation, which is responsible for the photoinduced shifts of the B 1s and Ag 3d peaks observed in the in situ XPS spectra. Solid-state NMR experiments including (11)B triple-quantum and double-quantum magic angle spinning (MAS) NMR revealed that up to six different boron species were present in the catalysts and only the tricoordinated interstitial boron (T*) species was in close proximity to the substitutional Ag species, leading to formation of [T*-O-Ag] structural units. Furthermore, as demonstrated by DFT calculations, the [T*-O-Ag] structural units were responsible for trapping the photoinduced electrons, which prolongs the life of the photoinduced charge carriers and eventually leads to a remarkable enhancement in the photocatalytic activity. All these unprecedented findings are expected to be crucial for understanding the roles of B and Ag dopants and their synergistic effect in numerous titania-mediated photocatalytic reactions.

The validity of using 31P NMR of adsorbed trimethylphosphine (TMP) as a probe molecule for discerning the types (Brønsted vs Lewis) and strengths of acid sites in solid acid catalysts have been studied by density functional theory (DFT) calculations. Brønsted acid sites with varied acidic strengths covering from weak, strong, to superacid, mimicked by 8T zeolite cluster models having different Si−H bond lengths and hence proton affinities, were examined together with Lewis acid systems having different metallic centers, e.g., BCl n F3−n (n = 0−3), AlCl n F3−n (n = 0−3), and TiCl n F4−n (n = 0−4) and their mixed halides. The theoretical 31P chemical shifts predicted for the hydrogen-bonded TMP···H complex and the TMPH+ adducts were −61 ± 1 and −3 ± 1 ppm, respectively, in good agreement with the experimental data. For the TMP−Lewis acid complex, a linear correlation between the calculated 31P chemical shifts and corresponding binding energies was observed for the B-, Al-, and Ti-containing Lewis acids, respectively, indicating the feasibility of using the 31P chemical shift of adsorbed TMP as a scale for Lewis acidic strength.

Post-synthetic dealumination treatment is a common tactic adopted to improve the catalytic performance of industrialized zeolitic catalysts through enhancements in acidity and stability. However, among the possible extra-framework aluminum (EFAL) species in dealuminated zeolites such as Al, Al(OH), Al(OH), AlO, AlOOH, and Al(OH), the presence of tri-coordinated EFAL-Al species, which exhibit large quadrupolar effect due to the lack of hydrogen-bonding species, was normally undetectable by conventional one- and two-dimensional H and/orAl solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (SSNMR) techniques. By combining density functional theory (DFT) calculations with experimental P SSNMR using trimethylphosphine (TMP) as the probe molecule, we report herein a comprehensive study to certify the origin, fine structure, and possible location of tri-coordinated EFAL-Al species in dealuminated HY zeolite. The spatial proximities and synergies between the Brønsted and various Lewis acid sites were clearly identified, and the origin for the observed EFAL-Al species with ultra-strong Lewis acidity was deduced to be at the expense of adjacent Brønsted acid sites. The excellent performance of such tri-coordinated EFAL species was furthermore confirmed by glucose isomerization reactions.