In this paper we provide guidance on a Bayesian uncertainty evaluation for a large class of GUM measurement models covering linear and non-linear models. Bayesian analysis takes advantage of useful prior knowledge on the measurand, which is often available from a metrologist’s genuine expertise and opinion, or from previous experiments and which is neither taken into account by the GUM nor by its Supplement 1. For the considered class of measurement models, we establish the equivalence with the related statistical models and derive analytical expressions of the posterior distribution for an appropriate family of prior distributions, which allows one to gain insight into the result of the Bayesian uncertainty evaluation. We extend this work to the formulation of arbitrary prior distributions for the measurand and provide some guidance to set hyperparameter values within a class of priors based on elicitation techniques, so that the resulting priors reflect the prior knowledge. Posterior distributions are calculated by Markov Chain Monte Carlo methods. We apply the Bayesian uncertainty evaluation to the mass calibration example of Supplement 1 and compare our results with those obtained by the GUM and its Supplement 1. In order to study the impact of the choice of method for this example, we carry out a sensitivity analysis of the results with respect to the choice of prior. We show a virtually strong effect of the prior distribution which results in reduced uncertainty estimates for a small number of observations. When using noninformative priors, we obtain results comparable to those achieved by GUM-S1. Python code is made available that enables a Bayesian uncertainty evaluation also in other applications covered by the considered class of GUM measurement models.
A multi-fidelity simulator is a numerical model, in which one of the inputs controls a trade-off between the realism and the computational cost of the simulation. Our goal is to estimate the probability of exceeding a given threshold on a multi-fidelity stochastic simulator. We propose a fully Bayesian approach based on Gaussian processes to compute the posterior probability distribution of this probability. We pay special attention to the hyper-parameters of the model. Our methodology is illustrated on an academic example.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.