Despite the popularity of antigen-retrieval techniques, the precise molecular mechanism underlying the process remains enigmatic. We examined the molecular features underlying the loss of immunoreactivity following formalin fixation, with subsequent recovery by antigen retrieval. To do this, we first created a molecular model using short peptides that mimic the antibody-binding site of common clinical protein targets. The advantage of this model is that we know the amino acid sequence in and around the antibody-binding site. We observed that some, not all, of the peptides exhibited the formalin-fixation and antigen-retrieval phenomenon. Other peptides did not lose their ability to be recognized by antibody, even after prolonged incubation in formalin. A third, intermediate group exhibited the formalin-fixation and antigen-retrieval phenomenon only if another irrelevant protein was mixed with the peptide before fixation. Amino acid sequence analysis indicates that fixation and antigen retrieval are associated with a tyrosine in or near the antibody-binding site and with an arginine elsewhere, implicating the Mannich reaction as important in fixation and antigen retrieval.

Despite the popularity of antigen-retrieval techniques, the precise molecular mechanism underlying the process remains enigmatic. We examined the molecular features underlying the loss of immunoreactivity following formalin fixation, with subsequent recovery by antigen retrieval. To do this, we first created a molecular model using short peptides that mimic the antibody-binding site of common clinical protein targets. The advantage of this model is that we know the amino acid sequence in and around the antibody-binding site. We observed that some, not all, of the peptides exhibited the formalin-fixation and antigen-retrieval phenomenon. Other peptides did not lose their ability to be recognized by antibody, even after prolonged incubation in formalin. A third, intermediate group exhibited the formalin-fixation and antigen-retrieval phenomenon only if another irrelevant protein was mixed with the peptide before fixation. Amino acid sequence analysis indicates that fixation and antigen retrieval are associated with a tyrosine in or near the antibody-binding site and with an arginine elsewhere, implicating the Mannich reaction as important in fixation and antigen retrieval.

We introduce a novel quality control technology that may improve intra- and interlaboratory immunohistochemistry (IHC) standardization. The technology involves the creation of standardized antibody targets that are attached to the same slides as the patient sample. After IHC staining, the targets turn the same color as the stained cells or tissue elements. Unlike current clinical practice, our proposed targets are neither cells nor tissue sections. To create reproducible standards that are available in unlimited supply, we use short constrained peptides as antibody targets. These peptides are attached directly to the glass slide. We show that these peptides simulate the portion of the native antigen to which the antibody binds. They are useful in detecting subtle changes in IHC staining efficacy. Moreover, the peptides do not degrade after deparaffinization or antigen retrieval treatments. This technology may be valuable in creating nationally standardized controls to quantify IHC analytical variability.

It is not clearly understood why some monoclonal antibodies bind to their antigens informalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue sections but others do not. To address this question, we analyzed the protein epitopes of 9 monoclonal antibodies that are immunoreactive after formalin fixation and antigen retrieval. We identified the antibody contact sites by using phage display and synthesized corresponding peptides derived from the GenBank database sequence that contain the predicted antibody binding sites. Our data indicate that all 9 antibodies bind to linear epitopes, ie, composed of contiguous amino acids. In addition, the amino acids proline, tyrosine, glutamine, and leucine are highly represented in these antibody contact sites. The epitopes tend to be mildly to moderately hydrophilic. These findings are the first detailed studies of antibody epitopes associated with antigen retrieval and suggest that antibodies must recognize linear sequences to bind after formalin fixation and antigen retrieval.

Even though antigen retrieval is highly denaturing, it paradoxically restores immunoreactivity after formalin fixation. It is unclear how this happens. We address this question using a peptide array to model formalin fixation and antigen retrieval. The peptides are linear stretches based on the native protein sequence, containing antibody epitopes of HER-2, estrogen receptor, progesterone receptor, and Ki-67. Of the 7 peptides, 6 retain their immunoreactivity after formalin fixation. However, if formalin fixation is performed in the presence of an irrelevant protein, immunoreactivity is abrogated, regardless of the peptides' amino acid composition. Fixation of an external protein around the antibody epitope prevents antibody binding. Antigen retrieval restores immunoreactivity. These findings demonstrate that native protein conformation is not relevant during antigen retrieval. Moreover, the loss and recovery of immunoreactivity associated with fixation and antigen retrieval, respectively, can be accounted for completely with a model of steric interference by adjacent proteins.

An important limitation in the field of immunohistochemistry (IHC) is the inability to correlate stain intensity with specific analyte concentrations. Clinical immunohistochemical tests are not described in terms of analytic response curves, namely, the analyte concentrations in a tissue sample at which an immunohistochemical stain (1) is first visible, (2) increases in proportion to the analyte concentration, and (3) ultimately approaches a maximum color intensity. Using a new immunostaining tool ( IHControls), we measured the analytic response curves of the major clinical immunohistochemical tests for human epidermal growth factor receptor type II (HER-2), estrogen receptor (ER), and progesterone receptor (PR). The IHControls comprise the analytes HER-2, ER, and PR at approximately log concentration intervals across the range of biological expression, from 100 to 1,000,000 molecules per test microbead. We stained IHControls of various concentrations using instruments, reagents, and protocols from three major IHC vendors. Stain intensity at each analyte concentration was measured, thereby generating an analytic response curve. We learned that for HER-2 and PR, there is significant variability in test results between clinical kits for samples with analyte concentrations of approximately 10 molecules/microbead. We propose that the characterization of immunostains is an important step toward standardization.

Even though antigen retrieval is highly denaturing, it paradoxically restores immunoreactivity after formalin fixation. It is unclear how this happens. We address this question using a peptide array to model formalin fixation and antigen retrieval. The peptides are linear stretches based on the native protein sequence, containing antibody epitopes of HER-2, estrogen receptor, progesterone receptor, and Ki-67. Of the 7 peptides, 6 retain their immunoreactivity after formalin fixation. However, if formalin fixation is performed in the presence of an irrelevant protein, immunoreactivity is abrogated, regardless of the peptides' amino acid composition. Fixation of an external protein around the antibody epitope prevents antibody binding. Antigen retrieval restores immunoreactivity. These findings demonstrate that native protein conformation is not relevant during antigen retrieval. Moreover, the loss and recovery of immunoreactivity associated with fixation and antigen retrieval, respectively, can be accounted for completely with a model of steric interference by adjacent proteins.

Background: Quantitative immunohistochemical (IHC) assays currently lack optimal reference quality-control material for cellular protein targets. To address this problem, we identified peptides that mimic the site on the native analyte to which the primary (monoclonal) antibody binds and used them as surrogate peptide controls. Methods: We identified peptide candidates from a combinatorial peptide phage-display library that mimic the epitope for the 1D5 estrogen receptor (ER) monoclonal antibody (mAb). The peptide inserts of the phage clones were sequenced. Several phage-encoded peptides were then synthesized and analyzed for affinity and specificity. Results: We identified phage clones that specifically bound to the ER 1D5 mAb. The binding was specific, in that the phage clones did not bind to two other isotype-matched mAbs. Their ability to bind the ER 1D5 mAb was related to the presence of a consensus sequence. Binding analysis revealed a Kd of 8.3 × 10−8 mol/L. The peptide was not recognized by any of 15 other mAbs commonly used for clinical IHC testing. Moreover, the peptide was able to inhibit the binding of ER 1D5 mAb to native ER, indicating that the peptide bound to ER 1D5 mAb at or close to the antigen-binding site. Conclusions: Surrogate peptide controls behave like the native analyte in terms of affinity and specificity. This technology may be especially useful when the native analyte is in short supply.