Vehicle control tasks require simultaneous control of multiple degrees-of-freedom. Most multi-axis human-control modeling is limited to the modeling of multiple fully independent single axes. This paper contributes to the understanding of multi-axis control behavior and draws a more realistic and complete picture of dual-axis manual control. A human-in-the-loop experiment was performed to study four distinctive phenomena that can occur in multi-axis control: performance degradation, axis asymmetry, crossfeed, and intermittency. In a simulator, three conditions were tested in the presence and absence of physical motion: the full dual-axis control task, single-axis roll task, and single-axis pitch task. Controlled element dynamics, stick dynamics, and forcing functions were equal in all cases. Results show that performance is worse in dual-axis tasks. Performance in roll axis is consistently worse than pitch, thereby proving axis asymmetry. Physical motion improves the performance and stability of the system. The application of independent forcing function signals in both controlled axes resulted in the detection of crossfeed in dual-axis tasks from spectral analysis. Using a novel extended Fourier coefficient method, the identified crossfeed dynamics can explain up to 20% of the measured control inputs and improves modeling accuracy by up to 5%. Dual-axis control behavior is less accurately modeled with linear time-invariant models and is more intermittent.
], [S.Barendswaard], [D.M.Pool], [M.Mulder]
@tudelft.nl).Abstract: In many practical control tasks, human controllers (HC) can preview the trajectory they must follow in the near future. This paper investigates the effects of the length of previewed target trajectory, or preview time, on HC behavior in rate tracking tasks. To do so, a human-inthe-loop experiment was performed, consisting of a combined target-tracking and disturbancerejection task. Between conditions the preview time was varied between 0, 0.1, 0.25 0.5 0.75 or 1 s, capturing the complete human control-behavioral adaptation from zero-to full-preview tasks, where the performance remains constant. The measurements were analyzed by fitting a HC model for preview tracking tasks to the data. Results show that optimal performance is attained when the displayed preview time is higher than 0.5 s. When the preview time increases, subjects exhibit more phase lead in their target response dynamics. They respond to a single point on the target ahead when the preview time is below 0.5 s and generally to two different points when more preview is displayed. As the model tightly fits to the measurement data, its validity is extended to different preview times.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.