No abstract

Objective To compare the efficacy and frequency of complications of transurethral interstitial laser coagulation (ILC) and transurethral microwave thermotherapy (TUMT) with transurethral resection or incision of the prostate (TURP/TUIP) in patients with symptomatic benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH). Patients and methods Forty-eight patients were randomized to undergo ILC, 46 to TUMT and 24 to TURP/ TUIP; they were followed for 6 months and the outcome analysed on an intention-to-treat basis. Results At 6 months the symptom scores and maximum urinary flow rate (Q max ) had improved significantly in all groups. At 6 months the mean symptom score was 9.2 in both experimental groups and 6.8 in the control group ( P > 0.05); the mean Q max was 20.6 mL/s in the control group, 16.2 in the ILC group ( P > 0.05 vs control) and 13.2 in the TUMT group ( P < 0.05 vs. the control group). In the TUMT group patients developing urinary retention afterward had a significantly greater increase in Q max than those who did not. The types of complications in the three groups varied. Urinary tract infection occurred frequently in the experimental groups, especially after ILC, whereas the 'well-known' complications of TURP occurred in the control group.Overall, 36% in the ILC, 54% in the TUMT and 73% in the control group had no complications (retrograde ejaculation excluded) during the first 6 months. One patient in the TUMT group underwent TURP after 3 months, whereas no patients in the ILC or the control group were re-treated for BPH within the first 6 months. Conclusion In the short term both ILC and TUMT are reasonable alternatives to standard transurethral surgery for symptomatic BPH, where the reduction of symptoms is the primary goal of treatment. However, both ILC and TUMT were associated with morbidity, although the complication profiles differed from those after TURP/TUIP. Both ILC and TUMT seem advantageous in some patients because of the reduced risk of bleeding and the eliminated risk of TUR syndrome, and because TUMT only requires local anaesthesia. Thus, as neither treatment is better in all aspects, the advantages of one technique over the other must be weighed when deciding how to treat each patient.

A prospective evaluation was done of 84 patients who were selected for transurethral prostatectomy based on the presenting symptoms and findings at cystoscopy. In addition, urodynamic studies were performed but the results were not made available to the urologist who selected the patients for surgery. Postoperative symptom analysis and repeat urodynamic examinations were done at 3 months in 68 patients and at 12 months in 50. There was no significant association between irritative symptoms and uninhibited detrusor contractions. Furthermore, no associations were identified between obstructive symptoms and infravesical obstruction as defined by urodynamic criteria. The study failed to identify a need for routine invasive urodynamic investigation of patients with benign prostatic hypertrophy.

We searched to review experimental and clinical trials concerning the capabilities of impacting on the ureteric and pelvic activity by means of pharmacological stimulation. Ureteropyeloscopy may cause high renal pelvic pressure. The normal pressure is in the range of 5-15 mmHg whereas pressure of 410 mmHg has been measured during endoscopy. The threshold pressure for intrarenal reflux is about 35 mmHg. Studies in animals have revealed that high renal pelvic pressures may cause permanent damage to the renal parenchyma. Furthermore, it has been demonstrated that elevated pressures may entail an increased risk of several complications related to endourological procedures including bleeding, perforation and infection. In other words, means by which intrarenal pressure could be lowered during endourological procedures might be beneficial with respect to clinical outcomes. In vitro experiments support the existence of different receptors in the ureter and renal pelvis. The ureteric and pelvic responses to the corresponding neurotransmitters have been determined. It seems that alpha-adrenergic and cholinergic agents are stimulating whereas beta-adrenergic agents inhibit ureteric activity. The effect may depend on the mode of administration. Drugs exerting advantageous effects in the pyeloureter may cause undesirable systemic side effects when administered intravenously. In animal studies, renal pelvic pressure can be significantly lowered by topical administration of beta-adrenergic agonists without systemic side effects. In vivo human studies are necessary to clarify the exact dose-response relationship and the degree of urothelial absorption of a drug before clinical use may be adopted.

In an attempt to identify preoperatively patients who will not benefit from prostatectomy, 84 patients with prostatism about to undergo transurethral resection of the prostate were evaluated prospectively with preoperative and postoperative symptom analysis and urodynamic examination, including cystometrograms. Of the patients 67 were followed at 3 months and 54 again at 12 months. Preoperatively, 65 per cent of the patients had uninhibited detrusor contractions, while 38 had persistent postoperative uninhibited detrusor contractions at 3 months. Patients in whom uninhibited detrusor contractions persisted postoperatively more often had unacceptable postoperative symptoms. Of the patients 13 per cent believed the symptoms to be the same or worse at 3 and 12 months. The incidence of uninhibited detrusor contractions in these patients was 57 and 71 per cent, respectively. While this finding suggests that persistent postoperative uninhibited detrusor contractions are associated with an unfavorable surgical outcome, we could not predict which patients would have uninhibited detrusor contractions following prostatectomy by use of preoperative cystometric findings together with detailed symptom analysis. Thus, we failed to define a role for preoperative cystometric screening of patients with prostatism.