The purpose of the present study was to investigate developmental changes in strategies used in reading. Pseudo words or non-words are often used in order to determine a subject's knowledge of an underlying rule structure when it is abstracted from its familiar semantic context. The Berko (1958) study on the child's implicit knowledge of morphophonemic rules is a classic example of this approach. Baron [in press) has pointed out that subjects may use a number of different strategies in reading unfamiliar words. One strategy is use of implicit rules at the grapheme-phoneme correspondence level (Venezky, 1974). A second possible strategy is to search for a familiar word by analogy to the known word(s). The analogies could be either in spelling or in pronunciation at either the syllable level as suggested by Smith (1973) or the lexical level as suggested by Carol Chomsky (1970).In post hoc interview studies both children (Glass and Burton, 1973) and adults (Baron, in press) report using analogy strategies in reading new words. According to stage theories of reading [cf Marsh and Desberg, 1973) the strategies should change as a function of developmental level, the young child beginning with a grapheme-phoneme decoding strategy and at some point, switching to direct lexical access perhaps based on the visual spelling pattern.The purpose of present study was to investigate whether or not the strategies used in pronouncing unfamiliar (pseudo) words changed as a function of developmental level.
METHODSubjects: The subjects were forty elementary school students (fifth grade); forty secondary school students (eleventh grade) and forty college students.Procedure: The subjects were asked to pronounce a list of 10 pseudo-words which were constructed so each word would be pronounced differently depending upon the strategy used. For example the pseudo word (tepherd) would be pronounced (tefard) according grapheme phoneme correspondence strategy and as tepard (as in shepherd) by an analogy strategy. The list of the ten words with their alternative pronunciations is shown in Table 1. One half of each group was given the printed list asa free response task. The other of each group was given the list as a multiple choice task where the experimenter pronounced the word both ways and asked the subject to indicate the a Reprints may be requested from Dr. Marsh,
The effects of stimulus and response abstractness and similarity were investigated in children's paired-associate learning of graphemephoneme correspondences. In the first experiment, stimulus and response abstractness were investigated in a factorial design. The results indicated that the major source of learning difficulty was response abstractness. In a second study, stimulus and response similarity were also varied factorially. Neither factor had a significant effect on the number of correct responses. The implications of the results for teaching grapheme-phoneme correspondences were discussed.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.