Models simulating the seasonal growth of vegetation have been recently coupled to soil-vegetation-atmosphere transfer schemes (SVATS). Such coupled vegetation-SVATS models (V-S) account for changes of the vegetation leaf area index (LAI) over time. One problem faced by V-S models is the high number of parameters that are required to simulate different sites or large areas. Therefore, efficient calibration procedures are needed. This study describes an attempt to calibrate a V-S model with satellite [Advanced Very High Resolution Radiometer (AVHRR)] data in the shortwave and longwave domains. A V-S model is described using ground data collected over three semiarid grassland sites during the Hydrological Atmospheric Pilot Experiment (HAPEX)-Sahel experiment. The effect of calibrating model parameters with time series of normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI) and thermal infrared (TIR) data is assessed by examining the simulated latent heat flux (LE) and LAI for a suite of calibration experiments. A sensitivity analysis showed that the parameters related to plant growth vigor and to soil evaporative resistance were the best candidates for calibration. The NDVI and TIR time series were used to calibrate these parameters, both independently and simultaneously, to assess their synergy. Ground-based, airborne, and satellite sensor (AVHRR) data were successively investigated. Both airborne and AVHRR NDVI data could be used to constrain the vegetation growth vigor. These calibrations significantly improved the simulation of the LAI and LE (rmse decreased by 21% for LE), and the site-to-site variability was greatly enhanced. The soil resistance could also be calibrated with ground-based TIR data, but the effect on the simulated variables was small. Although both NDVI and ground-based TIR data were suitable to constrain the V-S model, the synergy between the two wavelengths was not clearly established. Last, satellite TIR data from the AVHRR proved unsuitable for model calibration. Indeed, the AVHRR surface temperature values were systematically lower than both ground-based data and model outputs. The authors conclude that the calibration of a vegetation-SVAT model with shortwave AVHRR time series can be used to scale the energy and water fluxes up to the regional scale.
Remote sensing is an interesting tool for monitoring crop production, energy exchanges and mass exchanges between the soil, the biosphere and the atmosphere. The aim of the Alpilles-ReSeDA program was the development of such techniques combining remote sensing data, and soil and vegetation process models. This article focuses on SVAT models (Soil-Vegetation-Atmosphere Transfer models) which may be used for monitoring energy and mass exchanges by using assimilation of remote sensing data procedures. As a first step, we decided to implement a model comparison experiment with the aim of analyzing the relationships between the models' complexity, validity and potential for assimilating remote sensing data. This experiment involved the definition of three comparison scenarios with different objectives: (i) test the models' capacity to accurately describe processes using input parameters as measured in the field; (ii) test the portability of the models by using a priori information on input parameters (such as pedotransfer functions), and (iii) test the robustness of the models by a calibration/validation procedure. These 3 scenarios took advantage of the experimental network that was implemented during the Alpilles experiment and which combined measurements on different fields that may be used for calibration of models and their validations on independent data sets. The results showed that the models' performances were close whatever their complexity. The simpler models were less sensitive to the specification of input parameters. Significant improvements in the models' results were achieved when calibrating the models in comparison with the first scenario. remote sensing / modeling /experiment / surface energy fluxes / comparison Résumé-Modélisation du transfert Sol-Végétation-Atmosphère sur l'expérimentation Alpilles-ReSeDA : comparaison des modèles TSVA sur champs de blé. Le programme Alpilles-ReSeDA a été mis en place pour développer des méthodes d'utilisation des données de télédétection en combinaison avec des modèles de fonctionnement du sol ou de la végétation, dans le but d'estimer ou de suivre la production des cultures ou leurs échanges de masse et d'énergie avec le sol et l'atmosphère. Parmi ces modèles, cet article se focalise sur les modèles de transfert Sol-Végétation-Atmosphère qui peuvent être utilisés pour suivre les échanges d'énergie et de masse au moyen de procédures d'assimilation des données de télédétection. Dans une première étape, nous avons mis en place une expérience de comparaison de plusieurs modèles, avec l'objectif d'analyser les relations entre la complexité des modèles, leur validité et leur utilisation potentielle pour assimiler des données de télédétection. Nous avons défini trois scénarios qui répondent à des objectifs différents : (i) tester la capacité des modèles à décrire les processus en utilisant les paramètres d'entrée des modèles tels qu'ils ont été mesurés dans les champs ; (ii) tester la portabilité des modèles en utilisant des informations a priori en entrée (comme des f...
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.
hi@scite.ai
10624 S. Eastern Ave., Ste. A-614
Henderson, NV 89052, USA
Copyright © 2024 scite LLC. All rights reserved.
Made with 💙 for researchers
Part of the Research Solutions Family.