This work aims to carry out a comparative study between the apprenticeship system in the craft guilds in preindustrial Europe and the educational methods used in the European Higher Education Area (EHEA), with the aim of highlighting the role, within the field of engineering education in the EHEA, of the practice-driven approach (learning by doing), which yielded excellent results during centuries to craft guilds, since their institutionalized apprenticeship system was one of the reasons for their long-term survival. The transmission of technical skills and associated innovation were effectively supported by craft guilds but not as a main objective and even, sometimes, as a cause of undesired effects (formation of future competitors, revelation of secrets or shift of control over the production process from the owners of skills to the owners of capital. It has been demonstrated that both the organizational modalities or scenarios and the educational methods of the EHEA (except the binomial scenario-method formed by the theoretical class and the master lecture) used in engineering education, have a clear precedent in the preindustrial craft guilds, which emphasize the learning process instead of the teaching process and established, several centuries in advance and without intending to, a model for the EHEA. Keywords: Craft guilds; Apprenticeship; Learning by doing; Engineering education; EEES
The relation between scientific research and industrial design is fraught with controversy. While the number of academic PhD programs on product design grows because the discipline is in its infancy, there is no consolidated method for systematically approaching the generation of knowledge in this domain. This paper aims to review recently published papers from the four top-ranked journals in engineering design in order to analyse the research methods that are frequently used. The research questions consider the aim and contributions of the papers, as well as which experimental design and which sources of data are being used. Frequency tables show the high variety of approaches and aims of the papers, combining both qualitative and quantitative empirical approaches and analytical methods. Most of the papers focus on methodological concerns or on delving into a particular aspect of the design process. Data collection methods are also diverse without a clear relation between the type of method and the objective or strategy of the research. This paper aims to act as a valuable resource for academics, providing definitions related to research methods and referencing examples, and for researchers, shedding light on some of the weaknesses and challenges for current research in the domain of engineering design.
This research work performs a comparative study between the artisan mobility in the preindustrial Europe and the mobility within the European Higher Education Area (EHEA), emphasizing key aspects of the EHEA associated with mobility such as employability, technological transfer, social cohesion and receptiveness to new ideas. It can be concluded that, indeed, artisan mobility in preindustrial Europe was as a precedent for mobility within the EHEA, in the context of engineering education, from the detailed study of (a) movements of skilled artisan institutionally organized by states and political authorities, (b) tramping system, whose institutional backbone shows a clear parallelism with the organizational framework that supports the mobility within the EHEA, and that also contributed to overcome problems of information asymmetry in the labour market between local employers and itinerant workers, and consequently to solve problems of journeyman unemployment, (c) journeyman mobility as a teaching program integrated into the craft guild framework, which could restrain the information asymmetry in the commodity market by giving traceability and additional validation to the artisan instruction, and (d) minority migrations, which acted as a spur for the mobility within the EHEA because they allowed Europe to be aware of the importance of tolerance and receptiveness to new ideas. Keywords: Technology transfer; Employability; Labour mobility; EHEA; Preindustrial Europe
Mes / Año 9305 LOS MOTORES ROTATIVOS WANKEL, PASADO, PRESENTE Y FUTURO 1 2020 35 Veces 9267 ANÁLISIS ESTRUCTURAL DE UNA NUEVA PRÓTESIS CON ESTRUCTURA INTERNA PARA REEMPLAZO DE TOBILLO 0 0 24 Veces 9183 LA SOSTENIBILIDAD ENERGÉTICA: INDICADORES MACROECONÓMICOS Y SECTORES PRODUCTIVOS 0 0 22 Veces 9254 EL ALMACENAMIENTO DE ENERGIA LAS CLAVES PARA EUROPA EN LOS PRÓXIMOS AÑOS 11 2019 22 Veces 9448 MANTENIMIENTO PREDICTIVO PARA EL USO EFICIENTE DE AGITADORES INDUSTRIALES EN DESTILADORES Y REACTORES 0 0 19 Veces 8818 SISTEMA DE ROTURA DE VIRUTA EN TORNEADO UTILIZANDO LOS ACCIONAMIENTOS DE LA MÁQUINA 1 2020 16 Veces 8949 ESTRUCTURA MONOCASCO DE PLASTICOS REFORZADOS CON FIBRA DE CARBONO (CFRP) PARA COCHES DE FORMULA STUDENT 1 2020 16 Veces 9148 MODELO CONSTITUTIVO DEL COMPORTAMIENTO DE HORMIGONES DE ALTA RESISTENCIA A ELEVADAS TEMPERATURAS 1 2020 16 Veces 9247 INSTITUCIONES UNIVERSITARIAS SOSTENIBLES: DETERMINACIÓN DE GASES EFECTO INVERNADERO EN UN CENTRO UNIVERSITARIO Y ESTRATEGIAS PARA DISMINUIRLAS 1 2020 16 Veces 9612 LA NECESIDAD DE ALMACENAMIENTO ENERGÉTICO 1 2020 16 Veces 8837 ANÁLISIS DE ARQUITECTURAS TECNOLÓGICAS PARA EL NUEVO PARADIGMA DE LA INDUSTRIA 4.0 5 2019 14 Veces 9065 COMPARACIÓN DEL ABARRILAMIENTO PRODUCIDO POR UN ENSAYO DE COMPRESIÓN REALIZADO POR ELEMENTOS FINITOS ENTRE DOS TIPOS DE PROBETA 1 2020 14 Veces 9567 INTRODUCCIÓN DE IMPRESORAS 3D Y TECNOLOGÍAS DIGITALES EN LA INDUSTRIA DE LA FUNDICIÓN ARTÍSTICA 0 0 14 Veces 9167 MORTEROS DE ALBAÑILERÍA ELABORADOS CON ÁRIDOS RECICLADOS MIXTOS Y ESCORIA BLANCA 1 2020 13 Veces 9193 LAS DIFERENCIAS CULTURALES EN LOS NEGOCIOS INTERNACIONALES: ¿CÓMO ABORDARLAS EFICAZMENTE? 1 2020 13 Veces 9273 SMART ZERO CARBON CITY: FACTORES CLAVE HACIA LA DESCARBONIZACIÓN URBANA INTELIGENTE 11 2019 13 Veces 9166 LA INNOVACION ABIERTA EN LOS CENTROS TECNOLOGICOS: UNA EXPLORACION DEL FENÓMENO 1 2020 11 Veces 8831 HACIA UNA INFRAESTRUCTURA DE FABRICACIÓN FLEXIBLE, CONECTADA E INTEGRABLE EN REDES 5G 11 2018 10 Veces 9182 REVISIÓN Y 8665 ESTUDIO DE LA FRAGILIZACIÓN DE UN ACERO INOXIDABLE AUSTENÍTICO AISI 304H CON 15 AÑOS DE SERVICIO EXPUESTO A ELEVADA TEMPERATURA 7 2018 9 Veces 8889 UNA CONFIGURACIÓN DE REALIDAD VIRTUAL MULTIMODAL PARA EL DISEÑO CENTRADO EN EL SER HUMANO DE ESTACIONES DE TRABAJO INDUSTRIALES 3 2019 9 Veces 9298 ORQUESTACIÓN DINÁMICA EN EL SOFTWARE COMO SERVICIO 1 2020 9 Veces 9371 DESARROLLO Y VALIDACIÓN MICROMECÁNICA DE UN XENOINJERTO DE HUESO TRABECULAR PORCINO 1 2020 9 Veces 9400 INNOVACIÓN EN LA LOGÍSTICA: STARTUPS Y NUEVOS MODELOS DE NEGOCIO 1 2020 9 Veces 5763 SEGUNDAS VIDAS PARA BATERÍAS DE COCHES ELÉCTRICOS: BUENAS IDEAS -MALOS NEGOCIOS 1 2014 8 Veces lunes, 24 de febrero de 2020 Página 1 IdDoc Titulo Mes / Año 7894 CÁLCULO DE DISTANCIAS DE SEGURIDAD EN LA REPOTENCIACIÓN DE LÍNEAS DE CORRIENTE ALTERNA CON TECNOLOGÍA HVDC 9 2016 8 Veces 9132 ANÁLISIS DE CAMBIOS DE TENDENCIAS DE INDICADORES DE SALUD OCUPACIONAL EN ESPAÑA, EN EL PERIODO 1995 A 2017 1 2020 8 Veces 9363 RECONOCIMIENTO DE CÍTRICOS EN ESCENARIOS REALES BASADO EN VISIÓN ARTIFICIAL 1 2020 8 Veces 9424...
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.
hi@scite.ai
10624 S. Eastern Ave., Ste. A-614
Henderson, NV 89052, USA
Copyright © 2024 scite LLC. All rights reserved.
Made with 💙 for researchers
Part of the Research Solutions Family.