I have written a large book on the place of Duns Scotus in the history of metaphysics. 1 This is understandable.But I have written only a small book on the structure of theology according to Duns Scotus. 2 This is forgivable.What is less forgivable is that I have not taken a position on the place of Duns Scotus in the history of Western theology.What is not forgivable at all is that I have not taken a position in the contemporary debates on the appropriateness or not of the revival of radical orthodoxy.Why is this the case? Because I did not want to pass from the historical results at which I had arrived to the contemporary problem that one is asked to answer.For what is the question? According to Catherine Pickstock, it is that of modernity. "Given that attempts to improve society in a secular way via the state and market have so visibly failed, then perhaps this revised genealogy which stresses the legacy of a distorted religious theory could also point us indirectly towards a more serious alternative future polity than the liberal and post-modern critiques." 3 What means to we have to answer this? For Pickstock, it is clearly a question of an interpretation of the nature of modernity. Is modernity that which it purports to be: an autonomy productive of values and not owing anything to what precedes it? Obviously, not. Hans Blumenberg, in his work The Legitimacy of the Modern Age, has already shown that modernity rests on the metaphor of secularization, and that any secularization rests on the idea of the appropriation of the goods of the Church-and thus on the appropria-
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.