Therapist-patient interactions in 16 cases of brief psychotherapy were examined. Three types of therapist intervention (patient-therapist interpretations, patient-significant other interpretations, and clarifications) were compared in terms of the frequency of patient affective or defensive behavior that occurred in the three minutes following each. In addition, therapist-intervention and patient-response episodes were investigated to determine their relationship to outcome at termination of therapy. Results indicate that patient-therapist interpretations followed by patient affect bears a significant relationship to improvement at termination, whereas an intervention (of any type) followed by defensiveness correlates negatively with outcome. These findings suggest that an examination of patient-therapist interaction episodes may be more productive than examining process variables in isolation.
These data indicate that brief adaptive psychotherapy and short-term dynamic psychotherapy are effective for patients with certain types of personality disorder and that the two therapy approaches do not differ in overall outcome.
The study of immediate in-session processes and outcomes as possible change events as they vary across context has become an important research focus. In this paper we examined transference and nontransference interpretations, as well as clarifications (in-session processes) followed by patient affect or defensive behavior (in-session outcomes). Transference interpretations followed by affect are associated with a positive outcome, while interpretations and clarifications followed by patient defensive behavior are correlated with poor outcome. On a clinical level these patient responses can be thought of as sub-outcome markers. An affective response to a transference interpretation should serve as an indicator to the clinician that he/she is on the right track. Conversely, repeated defensive behavior by the patient should alert the therapist to consider a change in approach. Highly defensive patients generally have a lower level of object relations, less psychological flexibility, and diminished access to feelings. Careful exploration of the multiple factors operating simultaneously (and which are only slowly becoming evident to us), hopefully will yield data to guide future clinicians when clinical intuition is not able to make fine enough discriminations.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.