A proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA)-dependent complex, detectable after nondenaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, is formed between calf thymus DNA polymerase ␦ (pol ␦) and synthetic oligonucleotide template-primers containing a mispaired nucleotide at the 3-terminal position of the primer. This complex is indistinguishable in composition from that formed with a fully base paired template-primer. Extension of a mispaired primer terminus is a component of DNA polymerase fidelity. The fidelity of pol ␦ on synthetic oligonucleotide template-primers was compared with and without its specific processivity factor, PCNA. In the absence of PCNA, pol ␦ misincorporates less than one nucleotide for every 100,000 nucleotides incorporated correctly. Addition of PCNA to reactions reduces fidelity by at least 27-fold. PCNA also confers upon pol ␦, the ability to incorporate (and/or not excise) the dTTP analog, 2-deoxythymidine-5-O-(␣-phosphonomethyl)-,␥-diphosphate. A model is proposed whereby the increased stability (decreased off-rate) of the pol ␦⅐tem-plate-primer complex in the presence of PCNA facilitates unfavorable events catalyzed by pol ␦. This model suggests an explicit mechanistic requirement for the intrinsic 3-5-exonuclease of pol ␦.
DNA polymerase ␦ (pol ␦)1 is thought to be responsible for most DNA synthesis during mammalian replication (1). Together with its processivity factor, proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA), pol ␦ is responsible for the bulk of leading strand synthesis as well as significant replication of the lagging stand. It is thought that PCNA enhances the processivity of pol ␦ by binding to both DNA and pol ␦ and by acting as a "sliding clamp" that stabilizes the interaction between pol ␦ and template-primer (2, 3). On model template-primers, PCNA stabilizes by nearly 2000-fold the pol ␦⅐template-primer interaction (4, 5) and apparently increases the rate of single nucleotide incorporation by the polymerase (6).The dramatically increased stability of the pol ␦⅐template-primer interaction in the presence of PCNA has profound functional implications. For example, it was demonstrated by O'Day et al. (7) that PCNA could facilitate synthesis by yeast pol ␦ past a thymine dimer present in the template strand. Both cis-syn and trans-syn-L-thymine dimers could be bypassed. Similarly, the -subunit of Escherichia coli pol IIIholoenzyme, thought to be the functional prokaryotic homolog of eukaryotic PCNA (see Refs. 2,8), also affects replicative bypass of lesions, although in a complex way (see e.g. 9, 10). Finally, thioredoxin, the processivity subunit of T7 DNA polymerase and thus analogous to PCNA, also has effects on polymerase fidelity (11). In light of these many observations, we reasoned that addition to pol ␦ incubations of homologous PCNA might lead indirectly to an increased incidence of any relatively unlikely event (e.g. incorporation versus misincorporation).In the present study we analyzed the impact of PCNA on two different sorts of unlikely events catalyzed by pol ␦, 1)...