Verbeek J, Pulliainen M, Kankaanpää E, Taimela S. Transferring results of occupational safety and health costeffectiveness studies from one country to another -a case study. Scand J Work Environ Health. 2010;36(4):305-312.Objectives There are a limited number of studies about the cost-effectiveness of occupational health and safety (OSH) interventions. Applying the results of a cost-effectiveness study from one country to another is hampered by differences in the organization of healthcare and social security. In order to find out how these problems can be overcome, we transferred the results of a Dutch occupational cost-effectiveness study to the Finnish situation and vice-versa.
MethodsWe recalculated incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICER) for the target country based on resource use in the original study and the associated costs in the target country. We also allocated the costs to the employer, the employee, and tax-payers.
ResultsWe found that the ICER did not differ very much from those in the original studies. However, the different healthcare funding structure led to a more unfavorable ICER for employers in the Netherlands. Both interventions represented a cost saving for tax-payers and employees. Employers had to invest €10-54 to avert one day of sick leave.
ConclusionsWe conclude that results of cost-effectiveness studies can be transferred from one country to another, but many adjustments are needed. An extensive description of the intervention, a detailed list of resource use, allocation of costs to various parties, and detailed knowledge of the healthcare systems in the original studies are necessary to enable calculations.
Objectives: The aim of this paper is to study home care
clients’ freedom to choose their services, as well the association between
the effectiveness of home care services and freedom of choice, among other
factors.Methods: A structured postal survey was conducted among regular home
care clients (n = 2096) aged 65 or older in three towns in
Finland. Freedom of choice was studied based on clients’ subjective
experiences. The effectiveness of the services was evaluated by means of changes
in the social-care-related quality of life. Regression analyses were used to
test associations.Results: As much as 62% of home care recipients reported having some
choice regarding their services. Choosing meals and visiting times for the care
worker were associated with better effectiveness. The basic model, which
included needs and other factors expected to have an impact on quality of life,
explained 15.4% of the changes in quality of life, while the extended model,
which included the freedom-of-choice variables, explained 17.4%. The inclusion
of freedom-of-choice variables increased the adjusted coefficient of
determination by 2%. There was a significant positive association between
freedom of choice and the effectiveness of public home care services.Conclusion: Freedom of choice does not exist for all clients of home
care who desire it. By changing social welfare activities and structures, it is
possible to show respect for clients’ opinions and to thereby improve the
effectiveness of home care services.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.