Using the maximum hardness principle, we show that the oxidation potential of a molecule increases as its electronegativity increases and also increases as its electronegativity in its oxidized state increases. This insight can be used to construct a linear free energy relation for the oxidation potential, which we train on a set of 31 organic redox couples and test on a set of 10 different redox reactions. Better results are obtained when the electronegativity of the oxidized/reduced reagents are adjusted to account for the reagents' interaction with their chemical environment.
To assess the title issue, 38 hydrogen transfer barrier heights and 38 non-hydrogen transfer barrier heights/isomerizations extracted from extensive databases have been considered, in addition to 4 2 p-isomerization reactions and 6 others for large organic molecules. All Kohn-Sham DFT calculations have employed the popular M06-2X functional, whereas the correlated molecular orbital (MO)-based ones are from single-reference MP2 and CCSD(T) methods. They have all utilized the same basis sets, with raw MO energies subsequently extrapolated to the complete basis set limit without additional cost. MP2 calculations are found to be as cost-effective as DFT ones and often slightly more, while showing a satisfactory accuracy when compared with the reference data. Although the focus is on barrier heights, the results may bear broader implications, in that one may see successes and difficulties of DFT when compared with traditional MO theories for the same data.
Dipolar cycloaddition reactions involving munchnönes and simple dipolarophiles provide a versatile synthetic route toward pyrrole derivatives. However, despite their widespread use, there are still debates regarding the factors governing the regio‐selectivity of these reactions. In this contribution, we study the regio‐selectivity of 1,3‐dipolar cycloadditions of munchnönes and alkenes, and the ability of conceptual density functional theory (c‐DFT) descriptors to correctly study these processes. We base our analysis on the variation of different reactivity descriptors along the reaction path, calculated for the whole reacting complex, and for the isolated species, with the strained geometries they present within this supra‐molecular aggregate. The study of several global descriptors indicates that the path leading to the preferred product proceeds via an asynchronous mechanism, with the maximum extent of charge transfer occurring after the transition state. This helps to understand why several reactivity principles fail to correctly account for the position of the transition state in this case. This also explains why local c‐DFT descriptors fail to predict the observed majoritarian regio‐isomer. These results highlight the fundamental role of the distortion effects for determining the extent of charge transfer between the reactants, and thus their impact on the reactivity and regio‐selectivity in these reactions.
The regioselectivity of the 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of a model nitrone with a set of dipolarophiles, presenting diverse electronic effects, is analyzed using conceptual density functional theory (DFT) methods. We deviate from standard approaches based on frontier molecular orbitals and formulations of the local hard/soft acid/base principle and use instead the dual descriptor. A detailed analysis is carried out to determine the influence of the way to calculate the dual descriptor, the computational procedure, basis set and choice of method to condensate the values of this descriptor. We show that the qualitative regioselectivity predictions depend on the choice of "computational conditions", something that indicates the danger of using black-box computational set-ups in conceptual DFT studies.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.