Removal of antigenic components from candidate xenogeneic biomaterials is the primary success criteria for development of extracellular matrix (ECM) scaffolds in tissue engineering applications. Currently, the threshold level of residual biomaterial antigenicity required to overcome recipient graft-specific adaptive immune responses is unknown. Additionally, the extent to which the innate immune response tolerates changes to the native ECM, resulting from the ECM scaffold production process, has yet to be determined. This manuscript not only establishes the threshold for tolerable residual antigenicity, but also demonstrates that deviations in protein organization are tolerated by the innate immune system, provided macromolecular structure remains intact. In doing so, we provide the foundation of an immunologically-acceptable unfixed xenogeneic biomaterial for use in clinical applications.

Chronic vascular diseases affect over 25 million patients in the U.S, alone. While non-invasive therapies are available, approximately 4.5 million individuals are estimated to require a vascular bypass annually, worldwide. Autologous vascular grafts remain the standard of care; yet the absence of a suitable donor vessel results in approximately one third of patients being ineligible for autologous grafting. “Off-the-shelf” alternatives have been proposed, but have had limited pre-clinical success, primarily due to graft failure via thrombosis. Thrombotic failure risk has been shown to be dramatically reduced by the formation of a luminal quiescent endothelial cell monolayer. Recently, our group engineered an unfixed, antigen-removed (AR) extracellular matrix (ECM) scaffold from bovine saphenous vein (SV) which is minimally immunogenic and avoids in vivo thrombosis. However, the mechanism by which AR-ECM SV scaffolds prevent thrombosis remains unknown. In this study, we utilized cell culture, immunofluorescence, and RNA-seq to assess the hypothesis that hAECs seeded on the basement membrane (BM) surface of AR-ECM SV scaffolds adopt a quiescent phenotype. Cells seeded on the BM surface proliferated and underwent significantly greater XY migration than those seeded on the non-BM surface. Additionally, unlike non-BM seeded cells, BM seeding resulted in quiescent hAEC phenotype (i.e., apical polarization of podocalyxin and adherence junction protein (i.e., cadherin and β-catenin) colocalization). Finally, the transcriptional phenotype of hAECs seeded on the BM surface was similar to cells treated with simvastatin (i.e. “quiescent”) and significantly different from those treated with TNFα (i.e. “activated”) (n=6/group), as assessed by gene set enrichment and t-SNE analysis. We conclude that seeding hAECs on the BM surface of AR-SV ECM scaffolds induces a favorable “quiescent” phenotype, while an unfavorable “activated” phenotype is avoided. Ultimately, these results show that the BM surface of AR-SV-ECM scaffolds possesses inherent characteristics which promote quiescent hAEC behavior and resultant vascular homeostasis and will help inform future pre-clinical studies of this novel small diameter vascular grafting biomaterial.