Some mutations in FOXL2 result in premature ovarian failure accompanied by blepharophimosis, ptosis, epicanthus inversus syndrome type I disease, and FOXL2-null mice exhibit developmental defects in granulosa cells. Recently, FOXL2 c.402C4G, a new somatic mutation that leads to a p.C134W change, was found in the majority of adult-type ovarian granulosa cell tumors (GCTs). In this study, we investigated the possible mechanisms by which the C134W mutation contributes to the development of GCTs. Wild-type (WT) and mutant FOXL2 displayed differential apoptotic activities. Specifically, WT FOXL2 induced significant granulosa cell death, but the mutant exhibited minimal cell death. The FOXL2-induced apoptotic response was greatly dependent on caspase 8, BID and BAK because the depletion of any of these three proteins inhibited FOXL2 from eliciting the full apoptotic response. Activation of caspase 8 and subsequent increased production of truncated BID, and oligomerization of BAK, and release of cytochrome c were all associated with the apoptosis induced by WT FOXL2 expression. In contrast, the mutant FOXL2 was unable to elicit the full array of apoptotic signaling responses. In addition, we found differential TNF-R1 (tumor necrosis factor-receptor 1) and Fas (CD95/APO-1) upregulation between the WT and the mutant, and the silencing of TNF-R1 or Fas and the blockage of the death signaling mediated by TNF-R1 or Fas using TNF-Fc or Fas-Fc, respectively, resulted in significant attenuations of FOXL2-induced apoptosis. Moreover, granulosa cells that expressed either WT FOXL2 or mutant exhibited distinct cell death sensitivities on activation of death receptors and deprivation of serum. Thus, the differential activities of FOXL2 and its mutant may partially account for the pathophysiology of GCT development.