In the present work the interaction of different bitartrate isomers on the Cu(110) surface has been investigated systematically by using the Vienna Ab-initio Simulation Package (VASP), which performs periodical density functional theory (DFT) calculations. Among all bitartrate isomers the R,R-configuration is the most stable under the (3 1, 1 2) domain on the Cu surface. Its optical isomer, the S,S-bitartrate, is 10 kJ mol(-)(1) less stable in the same domain. This energy difference is sufficient to produce the distinct chiral assemblies observed after the adsorption of each optical isomer on the Cu surface. The calculations also showed that these domains are not formed due to intermolecular H-bonds, in contrast with the previous proposal by Raval et al.(Nature 2000, 23, 376). In fact, there is a formation of optimal intramolecular H-bonds in the chemisorption structures. A favorable packing orientation is also needed for the respective chiral domains. For instance, the S,S-configuration suffers from a destabilizing packing energy of 21 kJ mol(-)(1) under the same domain, due to a short contact between the H atoms of the hydroxy groups. These intramolecular H-bonds cause also some distortions on the bitartrate molecule, which appear to be dependent on the relative position of the alpha-hydroxy groups. The stability of the extended asymmetric domains, when the surface is modified by a chiral additive, might have important consequences for understanding and optimizing the properties of enantioselective heterogeneous catalysts.
To explain the formation of the asymmetric (9 0,1 2) structure for R,R-bitartrate on the unreconstructed
Cu(110) surface, we propose a model that takes into account the relevant interactions with the first and second
shell of neighbors and the influence of an adsorbate-induced surface stress. We suggest that the surface stress
occurs in the [11̄0] direction, when more than three carboxylate groups bind next to each other to the same
copper row. This stress is released if two or more copper atoms are left vacant between them. Considering
this assumption the surface stress and the relevant pair interactions of bitartrate have been quantified by
density functional theory. Employing kinetic Monte Carlo simulations this model was tested using all calculated
parameters, reproducing the experimental (9 0, 1 2) R,R-bitartrate structure. This confirms the proposal that
the empty trough is formed to release the surface stress caused by adsorption of R,R-bitartrate. This also
leads us to suggest that a similar mechanism is responsible for the formation of empty troughs in other ordered
structures, created by adsorption of similar molecules, such as acetate and succinate, on the Cu(110) surface.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.