Individual consistency over time in behavioral responses to challenging situations is usually regarded as an indication of the existence of animal personality types. Although such consistency has been found in a variety of species, information about long-term stability is scanty, in particular across different life history stages, for example reproductive and non-reproductive periods, which have the potential to affect substantially the behavioral responses of animals. In our study of adult female laboratory mice, we explored the stability of behavioral responses across a 43-day period by successively testing the animals on an elevated plus maze. We tested two groups, one group that had offspring during the first two tests but not during the last test, and another group that only had offspring during the last test. We found clear evidence of individual consistency over time by means of positive significant correlations across the different tests: animals that spent more time in the closed arms and those that entered the open arms more often during the first test also tended to do so during the second test-when still in the same reproductive state, and also during the third test-when in a different reproductive state. In addition, females of the two groups did not differ overall in their responses, although we found a significant increase in the frequency and duration of presumed anxiety-related behavior during the course of the experiment, contradicting the notion that habituation effects should attenuate the challenge of the test situation. In conclusion, our study strongly suggests the existence of stable personality types in female laboratory mice, even across different reproductive stages.