Aggression is associated with a host of behavioral, social, and emotional adjustment difficulties. However, some aggressive youth are perceived as "popular" by peers. Although these perceived popular aggressive youth appear relatively well adjusted, especially in the social domain, the emotional well-being of these youth is understudied. The current findings indicate that perceived popularity buffers adolescents who hurt others through relational aggression from internalizing symptoms. In contrast, perceived popularity did not buffer adolescents who engaged in overt verbal and physical aggression from internalizing symptoms. The results suggest that relationally aggressive perceived popular adolescents may be especially resistant to intervention if their aggression helps them manipulate their social worlds but does not contribute to internalizing symptoms.
KeywordsPeer relations; Popularity; Relational Aggression; Overt Aggression; Internalizing For many years, developmentalists defined high peer status as being well liked (i.e., sociometrically popular). Sociometric popularity is related, almost exclusively, to indices of positive adjustment (e.g., behavioral styles, psychological well-being, academic success; Rubin, Bukowski, & Parker, 2006). More recently, youth who peers perceive as "popular" have received increased attention (Cillessen & Rose, 2005). Understanding perceived popular youth is complex because their behavior includes positive aspects (e.g., prosocial behavior; LaFontana & Cillessen, 2002) and aggression, especially in adolescence (e.g., Cillessen & Mayeaux, 2004). Notably, although aggression is generally related to maladjustment (Coie & Dodge, 1998), perceived popular aggressors seem relatively well adjusted. For example, they tend to be socially central and prominent, athletic, and involved in extracurricular activities (Farmer, Estell, Bishop, O'Neal, & Cairns, 2003;Rodkin, Farmer, Pearl, & Van Acker, 2000). However, the emotional well-being of perceived popular aggressors is understudied.Externalizing and internalizing symptoms tend to co-occur (Lilienfeld, 2003). This work primarily focuses on overt verbal and physical aggression, but relational aggression (e.g., excluding/ignoring, spreading rumors) also is linked with emotional problems (e.g., Crick & Grotpeter, 1995). Explanations for the co-occurrence include that some causal factors underlie both internalizing and externalizing symptoms and that one set of symptoms may (Lilienfeld, 2003). For example, aggression may lead to life events (e.g., social censure, parental punishment, school suspension), which increase risk for internalizing symptoms.The current research tests whether perceived popularity buffers aggressors from internalizing symptoms. Knowing whether perceived popular aggressors experience emotional problems is important. Research indicates that adolescents experiencing greater distress (e.g., feeling unhappy/depressed, worthless, under strain) are more likely to seek help, including professional help (Rickwood & ...