A shell particle consists of a solid, nonporous core that is surrounded with a shell of a porous solid having essentially the same physicochemical properties as those of the conventional porous particles used as packing media in chromatography. The diameter of the solid core and the thickness of its shell or the external diameter of the particle characterizes the chromatographic properties of the packing material. The potential advantage of this particle structure would be the shorter average path length experienced by solute molecules during their diffusion across the particles of packing material when they are retained. Compounds having slow pore diffusion would exhibit higher efficiencies on columns packed with shell than with conventional, fully porous particles. Using columns packed with Halo, a new type of porous silica shell particles, we assess the gain achieved with this principle for peptides of moderate molecular weights and for small proteins.
The equations of the general rate model of chromatography and those of simple models (the POR, equilibrium-dispersive, and transport-dispersive models) are derived for beds packed with shell particles. Shell particles are made of a solid, nonporous core surrounded by a shell of a porous material that has properties similar to those of the fully porous materials conventionally used in HPLC. These equations have no algebraic solutions, but the moments of the peaks eluted under linear conditions can be calculated, affording the HETP equation for these columns. The discussion of the contribution to the HETP of the mass-transfer resistances shows that shell particles exhibit much lower plate heights for large molecular size compounds (e.g., peptides and proteins) than do fully porous particles, this advantage increasing with decreasing thickness of the shell. In contrast, the efficiencies of columns packed with shell particles and with fully porous particles having the same diameters are nearly the same for low molecular weight compounds. In practice, the gain in efficiency due to the use of shell particles to separate high molecular weight compounds does not depend on the thickness of the shell provided that this thickness does not exceed 30-40% of the particle diameter. For larger thicknesses, it decreases with increasing thickness. Shell particles can also be used in preparative chromatography. For compounds that have a high internal mass-transfer resistance, the gain in efficiency compensates the reduction in sample capacity due to the lower volume of porous adsorbent. For proteins like BSA, the production rate could be doubled. The gain decreases with decreasing mass-transfer resistance, e.g., with decreasing molecular weight.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.