In this study, we have developed, optimized, and applied a novel 3D in vitro cell culture platform composed of an interpenetrating network (IPN) that is both mechanically tunable and inherently bioactive. The IPN consists of a primary fibrillar collagen type-1 network reinforced by a secondary thiol-ene poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) network. The IPNs are formed via a novel strategy in which cell-laden collagen gels are formed first, and soluble PEG monomers are added later and crosslinked via visible light. This approach ensures that the collagen gels contain a fibrillar architecture similar to the collagen architecture present in vivo. We applied our IPN platform to study the effect of mechanical confinement on cancer cell behavior and found that it inhibits malignant-like behavior.