At the end of his article, entitled &dquo;Participatory Unionism,&dquo; Heckscher suggests that his union typology provides a useful framework to focus future research, and that &dquo;participatory co-management,&dquo; in particular, bears a closer look. Does his typology help us to understand variations in the level, patterns and consequences of membership participation within labor organizations ? Since most labor education professionals believe that increased membership participation is the key to strengthening the labor movement and to attaining progressive social change, and since the AFL-CIO has based many of its recent actions on this same premise, Heckscher's &dquo;Participatory Unionism&dquo; is both timely and relevant. I will comment briefly on the usefulness of the typology and then focus most of my attention on Heckscher's s last union type, and the real focus of his article, participatory co-management.
Heckscher's ConclusionsAt the risk of oversimplifying, I will briefly restate Heckscher's conclusions with the respect to the first three ideal types in his typology. First, radical unionism emerges and leads to high participation only under specific historical circumstances (war, depression, strong shop stewards movements), it quickly succumbs to the &dquo;iron law of oligarchy&dquo; or fragments due to competing intra-class interests (craft vs. unskilled) and &dquo;has no capacity to sustain itself or to unite workers in broad movements for change.&dquo; In effect radical unionism is a transitional type that, according to Heckscher, &dquo;tends at FLORIDA INTERNATIONAL UNIV on
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.