No abstract

We confirm that ultrasound is an applicable and safe alternative tool to x-rays in nondisplaced or excluded metaphyseal forearm fractures in children.

Sonographic algorithms for fracture evaluation (SAFE) offer a safe diagnosis and guidance of the therapeutic course of certain pediatric fractures, thereby reducing unnecessary radiation exposure.

Background Distal forearm fractures are the most common fractures in childhood and can be diagnosed with ultrasound. The aim of this study was to demonstrate the eligibility of Wrist SAFE for clinical use and the avoidance of X-ray application in children. Methods We enrolled patients from 0 – 12 years with suspected distal forearm fractures. They were treated according to the Wrist SAFE algorithm, a detailed pathway for ultrasound fracture diagnosis, treatment decisions and control options. Additionally, 9 clinical predictors were tested. Depending on sonographic and clinical findings, patients were treated with functional movement, immobilization or surgery. Follow-up was conducted after 5 days and 3 months. Results 16 physicians (6 specialists, 10 assistants) at 5 study sites examined 498 (234 boys, 251 girls, 13 not specified) patients with ultrasound, age 8.4 (0 – 12) years. 321 (64 %) patients were diagnosed with a fracture, 5 (0.8 %) with suspected fracture; X-rays were conducted in 58 cases (12 %), 9 (1.8 %) of them on day 1 and 49 (9.8 %) on day 5; sonographic diagnosis was confirmed in 57 of 58 (98 %) cases; in one case, the sonographic diagnosis of “contusion” was revised to “radius fracture”. 381 patients (77 %) underwent final follow-up after an average of 96 (62 – 180) days. All patients were symptom-free at that time. Palpatory bone pain over the radius/ulna and swelling were identified as clinical predictors. 81 % of X-rays were avoided. Conclusion Wrist SAFE enables the safe diagnosis and therapy of distal forearm fractures in children. Findings can be reviewed safely, also enabling physicians in training to use the method. 81 % of X-rays can be avoided, a figure that corresponds to 2.8 million X-rays in the G10 member states. After performing 100 examinations, physician have acquired the necessary sonography skills.

Ultrasound seems to be a valuable and safe alternative to X-ray diagnosis. Patients with inconclusive findings should undergo X-ray diagnosis.

Sensitivity and specificity of ultrasound examinations are high. Single study results show that sonographic examinations can be faster and less painful. In addition, the calculation model shows a tendency towards less-expensive ultrasound examinations.Further studies are needed with an adequate sample size calculation for assessing equivalence or non-inferiority of ultrasound and x-ray and to collect data on pain, examination time, and costs. The age of the older participants may be problematic because of the fact that epiphyseal plates close within the age from 15 to 22 years, which may influence the diagnostic accuracy of sonographic examinations. Therefore, future studies should contain age-stratified analyses. In addition, the calculation model for costs should be tested on a wider data base.

Ultrasound seems to be a valuable and safe alternative to X-ray diagnosis.

Fracture ultrasound has increasingly come into the focus of international research. A growing number of original articles and a meta-analysis show that wrist fractures can be diagnosed without X-ray in children up to 12 years. Further original publications state that elbow fractures can be ruled out by exclusion of intraarticular effusion and in proximal humerus fractures the number of X-rays is reduced by about 50 %, while the quality of diagnosis is improved. Screening for occult fractures is another good indication. Clavicle fractures, and ac-joint sprains can be diagnosed better with US than with X-rays. A number of research groups have contributed valuable research about the different indications. The aim of this paper is to give an overview of the basics and actual fields of application for fracture ultrasound of the extremities.